The foreign language glossed reader : authentic literary text as comprehensible input

Author

Avigail Rashkovsky

Date of Award

5-1999

Degree Type

Dissertation

Degree Name

Doctor of Education

Major

Education

Major Professor

Patricia Davis-Wiley

Committee Members

Ilona Leki, James E. Falen, John R. Ray

Abstract

The subject of this investigation is the use of vocabulary glosses (i.e., short definitions or explanations of the meaning of a written word), which are commonly used in foreign language readers and textbooks. Their acceptability, however, is determined by the prevailing views on FL teaching. While glossing does not contradict the traditional grammar translation approach, it appears controversial in the framework of schema theory, which suggests that background knowledge and top-down processing are the major factors in native and foreign language reading comprehension.

The widespread use of vocabulary glosses, on one hand, and their ambiguous theoretical interpretation, on the other, have provoked some researchers, in recent years, to investigate the effects of glossing on foreign language reading in Spanish, French, and German. The main issues addressed in these studies are: the effect of glosses on reading comprehension and vocabulary learning, as weU as how FL students perceive the use of this technique. The research findings of these experimental studies appear to be inconsistent, hence, further research in this area is needed.

This investigation contributes to our understanding of the effects of marginal glosses on reading comprehension and vocabulary learning by adding a new aspect, namely, Russian as the language of the reading text. The 30 subjects in this within-subject experiment had read glossed as well as non-glossed passages from an authentic literary text. Both their reading comprehension and vocabulary acquisition were measured by various tests, and a follow-up survey was conducted.

The results of the reading experiment statistically showed significant gains on all measures while the survey data demonstrated the subjects' strong preference for glossed reading materials in Russian.

Widely perceived in the theoretical field of SLA as "inevitable evil," glossing, nevertheless, enhances reading comprehension, increases vocabulary knowledge, and enjoys the strong preference of students, thus, motivating them to read. Consequently, there is an obvious need for developing foreign language glossed readers and other instructional materials, including software, where the use of glosses can be effectively employed.

Recommended Citation

Rashkovsky, Avigail, "The foreign language glossed reader : authentic literary text as comprehensible input. " PhD diss., University of Tennessee, 1999.
https://trace.tennessee.edu/utk_graddiss/8908