The emerging role of the private sector in the redevelopment of vacant railway terminals and associated properties in declining downtown areas: a case study of the Chattanooga Choo-Choo
ABSTRACT
Of the 40,000 railroad stations built in this country, over 20,000 have been demolished. Most of these stations, which were constructed in the late 1800's and early 1900's, were designed as monuments to the railroads and as symbols of a community's well-being.
The train station was also reflective of the confidence and technical competence of the industrial revolution. Its functional design, elaborate architectural detail, and structural soundness all combined to make the train station a legacy which Norman Pfeiffer has termed "uniquely American."
Since many of these stations were constructed at or around the turn of the century, they now tend to occupy key tracts of land which are within, or at least on the fringes of, the core of our downtowns. Due to the decline of passenger train service, however, a growing number of these railroad terminals stand vacant. Likewise, most of the areas surrounding these stations depended upon the railroad for their livelihood. As the passenger service became defunct, and the terminals closed, many of the areas adjacent to them also died.
The result of this has been a huge stockpile of decaying, obsolete, and vacant buildings. Until recently, it has been assumed that there was no alternative available except demolition and clearance of these structures. Within the last few years, however, it has been shown that there is indeed another, more sensible, alternative: namely, adaptive reuse.
This thesis has investigated both the theory and practice of reusing vacant railroad stations. First, it outlines the commonly accepted notions of the "how to" in regard to redevelopment activities in general. Second, it explores the private development process as it occurred in the reuse of Terminal Station in Chattanooga, Tennessee. Third, it discusses the impact which the Chattanooga Choo-Choo (a private shopping, hotel, restaurant, and entertainment complex) has had on the area which surrounds it. Finally, it compares the "theory" of reusing structures with the actual Chattanooga experience.
One of the major findings of the thesis is that the Federal, state, and local governments have, for the most part, failed to consider old train stations as a resource with potential for redevelopment. With notable exceptions, governments at all levels have not provided the leadership or the environments necessary to undertake realistic reuse programs.
Another finding was that the private developer is perhaps the most capable resource in terms of recycling old stations. This is due to the requirement which exists to make reuse projects "economically feasible" --a long-standing concern of the private sector.
The process of developing the Chattanooga Choo-Choo was an undertaking which took three years to complete, a relatively short period compared to many redevelopment projects. The findings point to four conditions which were essential to its success. These include: (1) the existence of a group of influential and well-positioned actors who were committed to the project; (2) proper timing; (3) capitalization upon a nostalgic theme and a unique name; and (4) a lack of conflict with the public sector.
There were four main components to this development process, which included: (1) assembling expertise and influence; (2) obtaining clear title to the property; (3) securing a large amount of private investment and the support of banks in long-term financing, and (4) application of "in-house" expertise during the planning and construction phases.
Another major finding was that the development process in Chattanooga differed little with the theoretical process. Also, the impact of the Chattanooga Choo-Choo on surrounding areas has been minimal due to the inward orientation of the project.
Finally, it appears that the private sector must take a more active role if a significant number of stations are to be saved. It is also imperative that the public sector act to private a favorable framework in which the private sector can pursue this end.
Thesis74.S557.pdf
12.57 MB
Adobe PDF
0b32c9606c6c5fe802bf5820e0f625e8