An evaluation of the cleaning effectiveness of selected commercial and experimental detergent systems on two flame retardant fabrics
ABSTRACT
The objectives of this research were to evaluate the relative cleaning effectiveness of six commercial and six experimental detergent formulations on two flame retardant cotton fabrics and an untreated control fabric and to investigate significant variables and interactions involved in the soiling and detergency processes. The study was designed to determine the effect of variation in type of soil, treatment for flame retardancy, and detergent composition on soil affinity and soil removal.
Conditioned specimens were soiled in an accelerotor using a dry, particulate soil or a composite, oil-bound soil. The soiled specimens were then washed in a launderometer using 0.2% detergent solutions under controlled water hardness conditions. Evaluation was based on reflectance measurements made before and after soiling and after washing. Statistical analysis was based on percent soil pickup and percent soil removal calculations computed from the reflectance readings.
Differentiation of soil type, type of flame retardant finish and detergent composition were identified as having a highly significant effect on soil pickup and soil removal. All three fabrics exhibited greater affinity for the oil-bound soil; conversly it was removed more effectively in all instances than was' the dry, particulate soil. The cotton treated with the Pyrovatex finish exhibited the best soil release properties, whereas the fabric treated with the THPOH-NH, and the untreated cotton were not significantly different in terms of soil release.
The main thrust of the study was directed towards evaluation of the relative cleaning effectiveness and key variables involved in the detersive systems investigated. The commercial detergents were selected on the basis of varying phosphate content; experimental detergents were formulated with reduced phosphorus and increased additive concentrations.
The detergents were ranked according to the percent of both types of soil removed from each fabric. In most instances, the experimental formulations were not as effective as the commercial products in terms of soil removal. Statistical analysis indicated alkalinity and phosphorus concentration were highly significant variables in the detergency process, whereas variation in additive concentration did not significantly effect soil removal. Generally increasing phosphate content and higher alkalinity were correlated with increasing cleaning effectiveness. Thus it was concluded the low alkalinity and reduced phosphate content of the experimental formulations were significant factors with respect to their inefficiency as cleaning agents.
"Tide", a high phosphate formulation, and "Cold Water All", a liquid citrate detergent, ranked similarily in cleaning effectiveness and were the commercial formulations recommended by this study for laundering flame retardant garments based on the reported acceptability of high. phosphate and citrate detergents on flame retardancy. "All", a medium phosphate detergent, was also found satisfactory in terms of cleaning effectiveness and reported effect on flame retardancy. AATCC standard .research detergent and "Sears' Heavy Duty Laundry Concentrate" were actually the most effective soil removing agents, however they were not recommended by this study for consumer use due to the commercial unavailability'of the AATCc formulation and the adverse effects of carbonate based products which have been reported on flame retardant fabrics.
Thesis74.R694.pdf
4.01 MB
Adobe PDF
1d150f9f1b2ebc00f730b70c8ee025e5