The jury and judicial legitimacy
The purpose of this research was to explore the role of the jury as a legitimizing agent for the judicial system within the governmental process. The jury was first placed in historical perspective and treated as an adjudicatory institution through which the government allows popular participation in judicial decision-making as a means of ensuring the public's acceptance of the "justice" meted out by the courts.
Second, the participatory role of the jury was reversed and considered not as an acceptance device but as a positive force in the generation of support for the judicial system. A theory of judicial legitimacy was then linked to the jury's "reverse participatory role." Propositions concerning two dynamics of participation-understanding and identification-were used to build a testing hypothesis which postulated that the attitudes of jurors toward the courts would improve following service on the jury. From this hypothesis a quasi-experimental design was developed to study jurors' attitudes in an actual courtroom environment using Q-methodology, a factor-analytic survey technique.
After conducting a successful pilot study among student-jurors in moot court, the experiment was implemented in county level civil and criminal courts, testing jurors on a before-and-after basis. The survey results revealed that the jurors' pretest attitudes were so positive toward the courts that they obscured any broad conclusions about the jurors' posttest attitudes toward the judicial system in general. However, the propositions and testing hypothesis were considered to be substantiated by the survey data within the more narrow scope of the jurors' attitudes toward the jury system specifically.
In conclusion, several other observations based on the survey data were made concerning the different interjurisdictional perceptions of the jurors toward the operation of the courts and the roles of the jury within the separate jurisdictions.
Thesis74.M3833.pdf
4.76 MB
Adobe PDF
35dc6b9590a0ea3c0bac71fe520ca861