A comparison of the effects of two methods of teaching physical education to lower socioeconomic status children and their improvement in selected motor tests
The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of the problem-solving style and the command style of teaching physical education upon the learning of selected motor skills in primary grade school children from lower socioeconomic class families.
Forty-two kindergarten and first grade male and female subjects from lower socioeconomic status families were randomly placed into one of three groups. These groups were: Experimental Group I (receiving a formal method of instruction); Experimental Group II (receiving an informal method of instruction); and a Control Group (receiving no instruction but having supervised free play). Each subject was administered four items from the Johnson Fundamental Skills Battery preceding and then immediately following a four week training session. Pretraining scores were compared to post-training scores and a mean difference score for each group was obtained. Using the least squares approach, one and two-way analyses of variance were run on the variables to determine if the scores were significant at the .05 level. The Pearson Product-Moment Correlation Coefficient was used to identify the existence of possible relationships that existed between the Johnson Fundamental Skills tests and each of the three groups in this study. Correlations were also run on the relationship between the subject's pretraining and post-training performance ranking (one subject's performance score in relation to the other subject's performance score).
The informal method group tended to show a slightly higher degree of learning selected motor skills than did the formal method group or the control group, although these scores proved to be statistically significant only in the kicking test. The findings indicate that there was no difference between males or females, nor between kindergarten and first grade subjects in performance scores.
When the interactions of the variables were analyzed, first grade subjects in both experimental groups (formal-informal) showed a statistically significant higher degree of learning running and throwing and catching skills than did the first graders in the control group. The correlation analysis showed that the four week training period had no effect upon any of the subject's relative performance rankings. The analysis also showed that the test items of throw and catch, kicking and the jump and reach test were all positively correlated to one another. The zig-zag run, however, was not correlated to any of the other tests.
It may be concluded from this study that there was no statistically significant differences between the teaching method used and the acquisition of running, jumping or throwing and catching skills. The informal method proved to provide the best opportunity for the lower socioeconomic status child to improve in kicking ability.
Thesis74.M378.pdf
4.11 MB
Adobe PDF
f06bf8b9ce0a5cf523d5b91c0d4cec88