An analysis of antitrust activity in the coal industry: 1964-1974
The primary purpose of this study is to determine the extent of antitrust activity in the coal industry and to ascertain whether or not the application of the antitrust laws in this area has proven efficacious. The time span chosen for analysis is the decade 1964-1974 because of the trend toward increased concentration in the industry and unjustifiable price increases for coal that were occurring during this period. The method of investigation is a case by case analysis of the existing litigations which are divided into two major headings, (1) acquisitions and mergers and (2) price fixing, bid rigging, and customer allocations. The former division deals with industry structure, while the latter is concerned with conduct of the firms in the industry.
The conclusions to be drawn from this study are disappointing from an antitrust point of view. There have been only a limited number of cases filed to prosecute or prevent antitrust violations in the coal industry, and many of these have not been effective in their purpose. The trend toward concentration is still continuing and the rise in coal prices has not been abated by the suits that were brought. Consent settlements are concluded to be an effective means of avoidance of punishment for antitrust law offenders. The availability of coal reserves is determined to be the key indicator of a coal firm's ability to compete for long-term requirements contracts of electric utilities.
Recommendations are made that should aid in the prevention of antitrust violations. It is suggested that special divisions be established in the Justice Department of the United States and the Federal Trade Commission to monitor company behavior in the energy industry. Consent settlements should be removed as a means of escaping punishment for "energy firms" accused of antitrust offenses. Coal reserves should be nationalized in order to insure a competitive allocation of resources. Private suits by injured parties should be actively encouraged to provide a further deterrent to anticompetitive practices.
Thesis74.H558.pdf
4.37 MB
Adobe PDF
11e6ba1cda17c591a9ff46df11b14e05