An analysis of perceptions of the reasons for compliance with criminal laws
The last five to ten years have seen a renewed interest, on the part of social scientists, in the deterrent effect of criminal laws. Empirical research to date has established only that the probability of being apprehended and punished for crimes is inversely related to crime rates. The severity of punishment can be related to deterrent effectiveness, but only if punishment is fairly certain. It is suggested here that perhaps a more fruitful approach to these problems would be to examine behavior from the standpoint of compliance, rather than deterrence, since reactions to legal threats accounts for only a fraction of compliant behavior.
A sample survey of Tennessee drivers was used in examining a few of the factors which might be related to compliance with criminal laws. Through an analysis of the perceptions of respondents (obtained in telephone interviews), it was found that age is inversely related to the degree of pragmatism revealed in reasons given for compliance with criminal laws; socioeconomic status and education are directly related to the degree of pragmatism. Age, socioeconomic status, and education were also all found to be inversely related to perceived probability of apprehension for crimes.
It was suggested, in conclusion, that future deterrence research should take into account the relationships between social characteristics and reactions to legal threats, a heretofore neglected area.
Thesis74.G874.pdf
2.69 MB
Adobe PDF
185f1f246b52a867918889095c7eeca7