The evolution of the eighth amendment in American constitutional law: problems and prospects
In recent years the "cruel and unusual" punishments provision of the Eighth Amendment has assumed major importance in American constitutional development, and this importance has been underscored by the recent death penalty decisions of the United States Supreme Court. In terms of doctrinal development and political impact, the most significant of these decisions is Furman v. Georgia where the Court held that capital punishment, as presently imposed and administered in the United States, is violative of the Eighth Amendment.
The Furman ruling and other recent decisions portray the growth of two principal constitutional standards for determining whether or not governmentally prescribed punishments breach the Eighth Amendment: (1) the "inherently cruel" test and (2) the "cruelly excessive" test. While these two standards provide a framework for judicial scrutiny of official punishments, they have proved troublesome for analysis. Lacking precision and clarity, they can be expanded or restricted depending on the ideological preferences of individual justices. The problem becomes even more acute when the justices are faced with an issue that deeply divides the American people. The justices interpretation of the meaning and scope of the "cruel and unusual' punishments concept can thus be as varied and intense as the larger debate in American society concerning the utility and morality of governmentally prescribed punishments. This difficulty is exemplified by the Court's recent ruling in Furman. The decision has proved to be the catalyst for a searching reexamination of the social and legal ramifications of capital punishment on the part of the federal and state governments.
While the exact requirements of Furman remain unclear, the Congress and those states wishing to reinstate capital punishment have apparently felt compelled to revise their procedures for imposing the death penalty in an attempt to comply with the ruling. This legislative activity, reflecting a variety of responses to an important Supreme Court pronouncement on a major aspect of the administration of criminal justice, promises to pose new and difficult constitutional questions requiring further judicial interpretation.
The Furman decision and the efforts of Congress and state legislatures to restructure the procedures for imposing capital punishment underscore certain assumptions about the capacity of the Supreme Court to influence the development of public policy in the United States. Given the variety of legislative responses, it is too early to determine whether the Court's decision in Furman will advance or inhibit recent efforts to reform the American penological system, but it seems clear that the political impact of this decision is of far-reaching and continuing significance.
Thesis74b.J656.pdf
8.13 MB
Adobe PDF
5e277e450a0638164ad17c08048b3518