Two-phase flow pressure drop and heat transfer characteristics of refrigerants in vertical tubes
Research was undertaken to study the two-phase flow characteristics of refrigerants in vertical tubes. An experimental study was made of the flow regime, pressure drop, heat transfer coefficient, and critical heat flux of R-114 boiling in a 0.785-in.-ID, 10-ft-long vertical tube. The boiling temperature was varied in the range of 100 to 250°F for all tests except the heat transfer coefficient runs where the range 100 to 200°F was studied. The mass flux range was 0.12 ≤ G ≤ 3.5 x 106 lbm/hr-sq ft.
The flow regime studies were made by observing the flow in a Pyrex glass section at the test section exit. They indicated that at low mass fluxes and boiling temperatures a large part of the flow was annular in nature. As the boiling temperature was increased, the bubbly flow regime increased significantly. With increasing mass flux, the flow became opaque and a frothy whitish liquid was observed, indicating that the liquid and vapor phases were mixing vigorously. Comparison of the experimental regimes with various flow maps did not yield any satisfactory results. The equations of J. L. L. Baker and the scaling of the experimental flow regimes obtained with one fluid to another on an equal density ratio basis were the only two ways found which gave close albeit not entirely satisfactory agreement.
The pressure drop results were analyzed by separating the gravitational, acceleration, and frictional components. While no entirely satisfactory formulation for the void fraction of R-114 was available, the Martinelli-Nelson model and a modified form of the Zuber et al correlation yielded results which did not differ appreciably from each other. The frictional component was compared to numerous correlations and the equations developed by Chisholm in a 1973 publication were found to give the best agreement with experimental results. This correlation was also found to agree well with other experimental data for R-11 and R-12 over a very wide range of boiling temperatures and flow rates. Only at very low mass fluxes in horizontal flow was this correlation found to be unsatisfactory.
The experimental heat transfer coefficient results obtained were compared to the ones predicted by numerous heat transfer correlations in the literature. None was found to be satisfactory. Chen's correlation exhibited the least amount of scatter although it consistently underpredicted the experimental heat transfer coefficient results. A detailed analysis of the different components of the correlation indicated that the Forster-Zuber pool boiling correlation with a variable coefficient or the use of the Rohsenow pool boiling equation resulted in a considerable improvement in the Chen correlation, thus reinforcing the concept of superposition. The multiplication factor, F, was also slightly modified. An experimental suppression factor, S, was obtained which was quite similar to Chen's although an effect of pressure was noted. An analytical solution was presented for S. It, however, could not be definitely confirmed since it was found to depend on the frequency of bubble generation from a boiling surface and little information on this could be found. Application of the modified Chen correlation to experimental data in the literature on horizontal flow indicated a lack of agreement at low flows--possibly due to stratification.
The critical heat flux results obtained were analyzed using the scaling law of Barnett and Wood and the scaling factor approach of Stevens and Kirby. Neither was found to be as satisfactory as the compensated distortion model of Ahmad. The critical heat flux data Dix obtained with R-14 were also compared to the present results and satisfactory agreement was obtained.
Recommendations for further investigation are given.
Thesis74b.J344.pdf
22.74 MB
Adobe PDF
0fbb7ace26c3328c8f0c5a2dc3845aa6