Attitudes toward accountability and trust in the performance evaluation of public school principals
Scope of Study
The purpose of this study was to examine attitudes of principals and superintendents toward the dimensions of trust and accountability in the evaluation process of public school principals in the State of Tennessee. A Likert type scale of equal-appearing intervals was devised to measure attitudes.
The instrument was based on the Tennessee Rating Guide and AASA's twelve evaluation types. Five demographic items plus two additional information items were tested against 23 scale items. The scale items consisted of 10 areas of procedure and 13 areas of content for principal evaluation.
The questionnaire was mailed to a 25 percent random sample of principals and superintendents in the State of Tennessee. Principals responding equal 314 or approximately 17 percent of the total population. Superintendent responses equal 26 or 17 percent of the total population.
The main statistical test employed was the t Test. The Guttman Scale was also used for ranking purposes.
Findings
No significant differences were found to exist between the Principal Group as a whole and the Superintendent Group as a whole concerning attitudes toward accountability and trust in principal evaluation.
When the two principal minority groups of the study including females and Blacks were tested against superintendents, the differences revealed were found to be due mainly to sex and race respectively and not to position.
According to the Guttman Scale rankings, the most popular procedure for principal evaluation is "mutual goal setting" and the least popular is unilateral evaluation. In content areas, "integrity in dealing with others" was ranked first while "after hours social life" was ranked last.
Within the Principal Group, significant differences were found to exist according to: sex, race, age, population of the school district, as to whether the system had a formal procedure for principal evaluation at the time of the survey, and perception of how completed evaluation results should be used.
Within the Superintendent Group, significant differences were found to exist according to: age, population of the school district, and as to whether the system had a formal procedure for principal evaluation in operation at the time of the survey.
Thesis74b.H622.pdf
5.86 MB
Adobe PDF
d4d0dd46fe358082fa14d964ae0557c0