Aptitude-treatment interaction and retention: a study of the differential effects of two teaching methods
This study investigated the possibility and nature of the occurrence of aptitude-treatment interactions at the college level and the degree of retention of material due to two different methods of instruction. The aptitude investigated was represented by prior achievement as measured by grade point average (GPA), and the treatment was two types of instruction: traditional lecture/discussion and self-pacing. Dependent measures were examination scores.
It was hypothesized that lower achieving subjects (Ss) would achieve better under the highly structured less threatening self-paced condition than in the intense discussion wherein implication, applications, and logical extentions of material covered were stressed with personal involvement in the discussions required. Higher achieving Ss should do better under the latter condition. It was further hypothesized that, disregarding achievement level, students would retain more of what they learned under the self-paced condition.
Fifty-four females at The University of Tennessee, predominantly in their second and third year of college, who were enrolled in a basic educational psychology course required of all elementary education majors were divided into two groups based upon GPA. They were then randomly assigned either to class or self-pacing in a counter-balanced design wherein they would receive one treatment for one-half the quarter and the other treatment the second half. All Ss were given study guides containing pre-tests, objectives, activities, and post-tests for ten weeks (one unit per week). Students in the traditional class condition were given check-ups (quizzes) each week while those on self-pacing were encouraged to take these check-ups at their convenience but attended no formal class sessions.
The first hypothesis of differential achievement was not substantiated. A Lindquist Type I analysis of variance showed the class condition to be superior to self-pacing for both achievement levels (p < .05). To check for retention a follow-up examination on material covered by the mid-term examination was done and also the final (which was independent--content-wise--of the mid-term). A Lindquist I analysis of covariance (GPAs for the two groups differed) was done on each of these. There was a significant interaction (p < .05) for the mid-term examination and its follow-up for the two treatment conditions. Though the class condition had scored higher at the mid-term, the self-paced condition scored higher three months later. Analysis for simple main effects showed both treatment groups to drop significantly from the midterm to the follow-up, but those in the class condition retained less. Results from the final and follow-up were not statistically significant but were of a similar pattern (the Ss who returned for the follow-up had scored higher originally in the self-paced condition--unlike the mid-term--and did not go down as much).
A further analysis was done to investigate the type of material retained best, by whom, and learned under what condition. Two Lindquist Type III analyses of covariance (follow-up scores from mid-term and final), with original scores being the covariates, were done on the two types of material tested upon--applied, problem-situation and association items or recall information. No statistically significant interactions were found from these analyses. Across treatments and achievement levels, however, Ss scored significantly better on applied material than on association material in both analyses.
Overall, the findings suggest that initial support for traditional class might not hold up when retention is examined three months later. What is learned under self-paced conditions is retained better. Under all conditions, applied material seems to be learned better than recall (or association) material.
Thesis74b.G743.pdf
2.49 MB
Adobe PDF
3b233b51f6523b53258227c829acfb76