Specificity of treadmill, leg and arm training
The primary objective of this study was to determine if the cardiorespiratory and metabolic adaptations associated with treadmill, leg-ergometer and arm-ergometer training are transferable across these training regimens. An ancillary objective was to determine the degree to which an exercise test is sensitive to physiological adaptations associated with training.
Sixteen subjects were partitioned into four groups. One group was a control, and the remaining groups trained either via treadmill walking, bicycle ergometer riding, or arm cranking. Training groups completed fourteen sessions over a three-week period; sessions lasted for ten minutes and required approximately 78 percent of the subject's maximal aerobic power on the respective training instrument.
In addition to pre- and post-training maximal aerobic power tests on each of the three evaluative instruments, subjects were also given pre- and post-training evaluative tests on the three instruments. These tests required about 78 percent maximal aerobic power for the respective instrument. Criterion variables were heart rate, minute ventilation, and blood lactate. Pre- to post-test differences, as a percentage, were analyzed via a four by three, groups by instruments analysis of variance with repeated measures on the instruments.
The analysis revealed that the training effect is specific to the training instrument. There was statistical support for this assertion for both the heart rate and ventilation variables. Although the lactate variable did not achieve statistical significance, the trend was similar to that for heart rate and ventilation.
It was concluded that if maximal aerobic power is unaltered by training, the training adaptations are specific to the training task. This is particularly true if work tasks are unrelated (e.g., treadmill walking and arm cranking). It was also concluded that evaluative tests which parallel the training tasks are significantly more sensitive to training adaptations than tests which are unrelated to the training tasks.
Thesis74b.G638.pdf
2.82 MB
Adobe PDF
d3a818ec37fbd39a1875a3b6a212cde9