The idea of the poet in the works of William Dunbar
Medieval poetic theory has received considerable attention in recent years. Much of the research has focused on the rhetorical treatises that were used in medieval universities to train clerks how to analyze and compose poetry. While the treatises represent the only extant discursive studies of medieval poetics, an analysis of the collected manuals tends to reflect the aesthetics of the educational system which produced and used them. A few attempts have been made to examine rhetorical elements of the treatises in the poetry of the period, but little has been discovered about medieval theories of aesthetics: the dimensions of poetic process, the idea of the poem, and the identity of the poet. The present study is an examination of the idea of the poet in the works of William Dunbar. As a Middle Scots poet writing at the close of the medieval period, Dunbar reflects a cross-cultural and cross-temporal aesthetics inherited from a variety of literary traditions. His most frequent persona voices are those of poets; he comments overtly and implicitly about the status of the poet and about the nature of the poem.
The major focus of this study is Dunbar's portrait of the artist. Chapter I sketches out the concept of the medieval poet which Dunbar inherited from several literary traditions: classical, Christian, Germanic, and Celtic.
All of these sources suggest a dualism in the identity of the poet. The poet was either a central figure in society, or he was an alienated wanderer; he was either a priest, or an entertainer; he was either a seer, or a maker; he was either powerful and self-assertive, or humble and unassuming. Dunbar's poetry examines these dichotomies in a more dramatic way than the discursive rhetorical treatises.
Chapter II examines the effect of Dunbar's selfconsciousness as a poet on his readers. His frequent references to the poet in his poems have led his editors, biographers, and critics into a variety of speculations about his life as a poet. Few of Dunbar's critics have recognized his use of personae as a literary device, even though they have struggled to assimilate all of his personae into a single identity. His portrait of the artist is not a single picture, but a triptych.
Chapters III through V examine the three predominant poet personae in Dunbar's poems: the poet persona as priest, the poet persona as courtier, and the poet persona as makar. A study of a number of representative poems reveals that many of the dichotomies surrounding the identity of the poet in Dunbar's inherited literary traditions are reflected in his psychological studies of the poet as priest, courtier, and makar.
Finally, Chapter VI examines the theme of the poem as an artifact of personal experience. Dunbar appears to draw dualistic judgments about poetry which match the dualistic ideas in his three portraits of the poet. He suggests that poetry can be either truth or lies, creation or imitation, prophecy or flattery, sacred or profane. This study suggests that theoretical ideas about the poet, his processes, and his poetry are not confined to the explicit discursive studies of poetics in the medieval period, but can also be traced through the poetry of William Dunbar.
Thesis74b.G386.pdf
11.25 MB
Adobe PDF
4524385871aaee57d3842e7aa5c69c67