Organizational leadership, technological conditions, and the effective performance of industrial supervisors
Field studies of leadership effectiveness have not taken into account the structural and situational differences that affect social influence processes in the formal organization. By taking a "low level" approach to the development of theory, i.e., that relating only to leadership effectiveness in the industrial setting, it was possible to conceptualize the ways in which technology affects (1) the formal structure of the organization, (2) the nature of its administrative and social control processes, and (3) the situational demands upon the foreman and his work group. In this view, leadership is considered to be an integral part of the ongoing organization and is likely to reflect many of the company's unique features. Which supervisory behavior patterns are appropriate to effective task accomplishment depend upon these structural and situational factors. On the other hand, a much more general relationship exists between leader behavior and subordinate satisfaction. Based on this dichotomy, it was possible to develop a multifaceted contingency model of leadership effectiveness for firstline supervisors in the industrial setting.
Three organizations thought to be representative of their technological types (Woodward, 1965) were selected for study. Questionnaires were administered to foremen, their immediate superiors, and their subordinates. All respondents described the control or influence structure of their organization (Tannenbaum, 1968). Subordinates completed the Leader Behavior Description Questionnaire (Stogdill, 1963) and indicated their degree of job satisfaction (Smith, et al., 1969). Superiors evaluated the overall job performance of foremen and the extent to which they fulfilledvarious role requirements. Finally, the foremen themselves provided peer nominations of successful job performance along the same performance dimensions, and described the situational variables that affected their work groups (Yukl, 1969). The approach involved testing of hypotheses derived from organization theory and a review of the literature on industrial leadership, in order to determine how technological conditions affect leadership-satisfaction and leadership-performance relationships. Comparative analysis of leadership effectiveness in different types of production systems were carried out and the effects of within-organization situational differences were investigated.
Of immediate interest was the social control structure which was thought to vary according to the type of production system. Predicted rankings based on organization theory suggested that the amount of social control exercised at lower levels in the organization may be less in technologically advanced production systems, and that the existence of large differentials between levels occurred in the mass production firm. Thus it appeared that the nature of the overall production task constrains the amount and distribution of control in the organization. This has serious implications for the study of leadership in more advanced production technologies since less social influence is exercised at the lower levels and the impact of the foreman's behavior on organizational effectiveness may be less than in unit/small batch production systems.
Concerning the leadership-satisfaction relationship, consideration was found to be important regardless of technological, situational or individual differences, thereby confirming the most general finding in the research literature. Additionally, however, it was found that different dimensions of leader behavior contribute additionally to worker satisfaction in unit/small batch and mass production firms. In contrast there were no consistent relations found with respect to performance effectiveness suggesting that different patterns of behavior relate to successful task accomplishment under different technological conditions. However, it did appear in the three companies studied that leadership was more strongly related to performance in the unit/small batch firm than in firms with more advanced production technologies. While the results with respect to performance were not conclusive, the theoretical framework was judged to be adequate for future investigations of leadership effectiveness of supervisors in industrial organizations.
Thesis74b.G372.pdf
10.3 MB
Adobe PDF
1740ccc2e8923f6b76ea42f736e081dd