The value of an individualized instruction approach for teaching business and office occupations
The purpose of the study was to determine whether learning activity packages as a method of teaching obtains similar results when compared with the conventional textbook method for selected high school students in the Florida and Tennessee secondary schools.
The objectives were: (1) to determine if the low- or high-ability student performs best on learning activity packages, (2) to determine if the occupation of the parents of students has an influence on student achievement, (3) to determine if learning activity packages produce superior results for students learning the material, (4) to determine if the teacher perception of individualized instruction influences student achievement, and (5) to determine if inservice training of teachers helps promote student achievement.
The hypothesis was: There is no difference at the .05 level of significance in achievement for students who are taught by learning activity packages as compared with students who are taught by the conventional textbook method.
Five Florida and five Tennessee intact classes were compared in carrying out the study. The 108 students from Florida who had participated in instruction by use of learning activity packages in Duval County during the 1972-73 school year formulated the experimental group. The 124 nonlearning activity package students formed the control group. Both student groups had instruction in the subject of office practice covering the specific areas of (1) filing, (2) grooming, (3) computational skills, (4) processing forms, (5) mail handling, (6) record keeping, (7) telephone techniques, and (8) human relations, in the secondary schools where they were taught.
The pre- and post-test scores in addition to supplementary data from students' permanent records from each school comprised the data for this study. An information sheet was used to organize the data. By using the form, including the card column for each item, the coding and keypunching were accomplished. Three packaged programs at The University of Tennessee Computer Center, Knoxville were used in treating the data statistically: (1) The Statistical Package for Social Studies (SPSS) was used for Chi Square and Spearman's Rho computations. Chi Square was used to determine significant relationships between inservice training of teachers and the achievement by their students on the scores for the learning activity packages. Spearman's Rho was used to determine significant correlation between occupation of the parents of students and the achievement by their students on the scores for the learning activity packages. (2) The Statistical Analysis System (SAS) computer program provided an Analysis of Covariance. This statistical treatment was needed to determine significant differences at the .05 level in achievement for students who were taught by learning activity packages as compared with students who were taught by the conventional textbook method. (3) The Biserial Correlation Coefficient computer program was used to determine the correlation between teacher perception of individualized instruction and student achievement on the scores for the learning activity packages.
The conclusions from the study were: (1) The learning activity packages is an effective method for learning office practice content, (2) High ability students performed better on learning activity packages than do low ability students, (3) The occupation of the father seems to have an effect on student achievement, but the occupation of the mother does not seem to have an effect, (4) Teacher perception of individualized instruction seems to have no influence on student achievement, and (5) Inservice training seems to have no overall effect on student achievement.
Thesis74b.A335.pdf
8.69 MB
Adobe PDF
acfab80f5d21fcbded5989d86d6d5217