Identification of problems associated with two approaches to junior high school prevocational education
The primary objective of this study was to identify and categorize problems associated with the two approaches to prevocational education. Questions to be answered were: Are problems encountered in each approach unique to that approach? Are problems encountered in both approaches similar?
The Delphi Technique was used to obtain data from program administrators who were utilizing two differing approaches to prevocational education in four states, namely Maryland, North Carolina, Tennessee and Virginia. The total population consisted of seventy-seven prevocational program administrators, forty utilizing a separate course approach and thirty-seven utilizing an integrated approach. The population was obtained by identifying from each of the four states the state director for vocational education, a teacher educator from the institution with the EPDA leadership program, the state department leader for Career Education, the state AVA leader, and the executive director of the state's Advisory Council on Vocational Education. Each of these persons was asked to identify programs in his state utilizing an integrated approach to prevocational education and programs utilizing a separate course approach. From the combined listing of the five vocational leaders in each of the states, ten programs from each approach were randomly selected, or all that were identified if less than ten; thus, a total of twenty programs from the states of Maryland (ten separate course and ten integrated), twenty programs from North Carolina (ten separate course and ten integrated), twenty programs from Tennessee (ten separate course and ten integrated), and seventeen programs from Virginia (ten separate course and seven integrated) comprised the total population. The administrators of these programs were sent a series of three probes.
The Delphi Technique was used to gather data from the field. Delphi I requested a listing of problems. Thirty-four integrated approach administrators responded with a total of 117 problems and the entire population of 40 separate course approach administrators responded with a total of 111 problems. These were analyzed and categorized for each approach and returned as Delphi II for rating. A four point rating scale was used to determine majority views. Delphi III, sent to the seventy-two administrators who returned the second probe, required the administrators to review the ratings and to agree or disagree with the majority rating as to the importance of the problems. In the event of disagreement, the administrators stated their reasons for disagreement. A total of sixty-nine participants, or 90 percent of the original population returned the final probe.
After analyzing the data the following conclusions were drawn:
1. There are different problems associated with the two approaches to prevocational education. Therefore, when considering implementation of a prevocational program, the program planner should evaluate existing personnel, facilities, scheduling and attitudes, in order to select the approach which his school or system can best deal with in light of anticipated problems.
2. Common problem areas outnumber the unique problem areas. Similar objectives give rise to common administrative problems in leadership, curriculum, instruction, materials and equipment, and funding. Preservice and inservice training could be made available in these areas for administrators without regard to approach utilized.
3. Personnel is a critical problem area regardless of approach utilized. Inclusion or adoption of a new program requires special attention and training given to the personnel involved.
4. Problems identified could be used as a basis for inservice training for administrators in order to evaluate alternative solutions on the basis of local conditions and resources.
On the basis of these conclusions, it was recommended that:
1. Problems identified for each approach to prevocational education be reviewed by those initiating new programs and scrutinized in light of objectives, resources, and local conditions.
2. The American Vocational Association take the leadership in establishing a formal organization for prevocational administrators and practitioners. This group should then, standardize terminology and provide lines of communication for the exchange of ideas concerning various aspects of prevocational education.
3. Teacher education institutions make a greater effort to incorporate world of work concepts in all phases of the preservice preparation of teachers.
4. Workshops be conducted for prevocational administrators according to need. Workshops should be jointly planned by public schools and teacher preparation institutions. Tuition free credit or additional remuneration should be provided for the participants.
5. State departments of education look more closely at funding levels and procedures for prevocational education.
6. Program administrators and prevocational teachers give emphasis to establishing positive attitudes within the school and community. All teachers should be informed and aware of the objectives and contributions of the prevocational program. Efforts should be made to inform school and system administrators of the purposes of prevocational education. Every opportunity should be taken to present the goals and achievements of prevocational programs to parents and the community.
7. Writers and researchers in vocational education give attention to the problems involved in both approaches to prevocational education.
Thesis75b.W333.pdf
5.62 MB
Adobe PDF
0f9d1a61a2aab6d083da1baac55ea926