A proposed learning hierarchy for needs assessment
The purpose of this study was to construct a learning hierarchy for training persons in needs assessment. Content and logical analysis were applied to writings in the field of needs assessment to produce a learning hierarchy which would be approved by experts in the field of needs assessment.
A four-phased hierarchy was constructed, including 70 tasks which a student of needs assessment would master. Expressed behaviorally, the hierarchy provided a basis for testing and remediation at any level. Practitioner criticism was sought and the hierarchy was slightly revised.
Three experts, working as a team on an evaluation project, reviewed the proposed hierarchy. In individual and consecutive two hour sessions, they viewed the proposed hierarchy, interacted with the hierarchy, and rated the task statements. A gaming strategy was used to stimulate expert manipulation of the hierarchy. . Each task was presented on a card, coded by color, size, and position, and the expert was asked to add, rearrange, or delete as needed. "Bogus" cards were included to guard against expert response acquiescence. After structure and sequence was explored, the expert was asked to judge the value of each task, using a card sort technique. The results showed an addition of 37 tasks, with no tasks deleted, and some structural rearrangement. Experts judged all proposed tasks as "important" to "extremely important." Comments from experts supported these ratings, as they viewed the hierarchy as a useful and needed curriculum.
A revised hierarchy, based on the proposed hierarchy with the additions and restructuring of the experts, was prepared. The recommendation was made that a companion study be undertaken to test each learning task and sequence as a hypothesis. To further assess the validity of the model, learner data must be gathered.
Thesis75b.W244.pdf
3.9 MB
Adobe PDF
dd73c34f956f9c8b7c52dce82530f5e4