A study of the effects of antecedent conditions on the different kinds of problems perceived by teachers when implementing curriculum change
The problem in this study was to determine how certain conditions antecedent to the teaching act influenced the kinds of problems perceived by teachers when implementing curriculum change. Specifically, these antecedent conditions were teacher attitudes about teaching children as measured by the Minnesota Teachers' Attitude Inventory, age, educational preparation and teaching experience.
The sample which provided the data for this study was the teachers who implemented the 1973-74 Kentucky Pilot Kindergarten Program. The initial 100 units provided pilot programs for study pending a complete state supported kindergarten program.
The data obtained represented the problems perceived in implementing a new educational program. A Q-sort composed of anticipated problems submitted by each teacher was analyzed in terms of two main effect factors that distinguished the kinds of problems perceived in either the nomothetic dimension or in the idiographic dimension. Q-sort arrays were arranged for groups classified by antecedent variables and each subclassification was created in terms of factor scores for the two main effects, the expectations dimension and the concern orientation. Three levels of the expectations dimension were nomothetic, transactional and idiographic expectations. Four levels of the concern orientation factor were concern for institutional or program needs, group needs, self needs, or individual child needs.
Analysis of variance between each antecedent variable grouping and within each subgroup yielded highly significant levels of variance between the kinds of problems perceived among groups and within groups. The significant variance distinguished the kinds of problems perceived in either the nomothetic or the idiographic dimensions, thereby verifying the effect of antecedent conditions on perception.
All antecedent group scores varied significantly in terms of the expectation dimension factor to support the following major conclusions regarding the problem perception of the teachers who implemented the 100 units in the Kentucky Pilot Kindergarten Program: (1) attitude was an antecedent to perception which was significantly related to the kinds of problems perceived; (2) age was an antecedent to perception which was significantly related to the kinds of problems perceived; and (3) teaching experience was an antecedent to perception which was significantly related to the kinds of problems perceived.
More specifically, teachers with low attitude scores perceived problems in the nomothetic expectations dimension and concerns orientation. Teachers with high attitudes scores perceived more problems in personalizing roles. Younger teachers, though more concerned about their own personal needs than the median age group, perceived problems in personalizing roles or the idiographic frame of reference. Although the results were not consistently significant, teachers originally prepared to teach the youngest pupils tended to differ from those who majored in teaching older children specific subjects. Their expectations for acceptable behavior or conditions tended to be idiographic, whereas the teachers prepared to teach older children perceived normative problems in socializing individuals. Teaching experience influenced significantly the kinds of problems perceived with beginning teachers exhibiting more concerns for themselves and the child. More experienced teachers with a varied experience background focused their concerns more exclusively on the child, and these concerns involved more idiographic expectations than perceived by less widely experienced teachers.
Thesis75b.V253.pdf
5.19 MB
Adobe PDF
92e019bd065edd9caa617dc09da3ec18