Determining the effects of two differential self-modeling techniques on the acquisition of appropriate counseling behaviors of counselor trainees
Purpose
The major purpose of the study was to access the efficacy of two different self-modeling techniques and practice-only on the acquisition of probes, affect reflections, and focus on client statements by counselor trainees. The three techniques compared were self-modeling exposure to counseling behavior patterns; self-modeling exposure to randomly selected video feedback; and practice without video feedback.
Method
Fifteen beginning practicum students from the Department of Educational Psychology and Guidance at The University of Tennessee were randomly divided into the three treatment groups. The subjects in each group conducted four videotaped individual interviews with coached clients. For the Self-Modeling, Counseling Behavior treatment group, the researcher and two VTR technicians prepared three ten-minute modeling tapes of counseling behaviors the subjects had used in their first, second, and third interviews. The subjects' behaviors were duplicated onto the modeling tape from the original interview tape via two Sony VTR units. Subjects were shown each modeling tape immediately before their next interview. . There was no verbal approval given to the subjects during or following their viewing of the playback tapes.
Preparation of the tapes for the Self-Modeling, Randomly Selected Feedback group involved the duplication of three unrelated three to fourminute segments of each of the first through third interviews onto a ten-minute self-modeling tape. The subjects viewed their randomly selected playbacks immediately before the second, third and fourth interviews, without the intervention of the researcher.
Subjects in the Practice, No Video Feedback group were not shown portions of their videotaped interviews until after the data were collected. All subjects in the three groups were given written feedback sheets before each of the final three interviews.
The first and fourth tapes of each subject were retained for evaluation. Three judges were extensively trained to recognize and rate the counseling behaviors selected as dependent variables. The judges were required to. obtain a 90 percent-plus interater reliability score before rating the tapes. Five subsequent reliability checks were conducted during the rating procedure.
Results
Ratio scores were obtained for each of the dependent variables on the pre- and post-treatment trials. After the ratios were converted to percentages the effectiveness of the experimental conditions was determined by accessing changes in the percentages of appropriate response as a function of the conditions. Both pooled and individual subject data were illustrated through the use of line graphs.
Examination of the pooled subject data revealed a trend favoring the Counseling Behavior Self-Modeling treatment as the most efficacious method of teaching the counseling skills. Pooled subjects in this group scored higher on all dependent variables at the final trial than subjects in the other two groups. All pooled pre- and post-changes in the Counseling Behavior group were in a positive direction.
Individually graphed data were similar to the pooled subject data. In the group exposed to only counseling behaviors 13 out of 15 possible changes were positive. This compared to 7 positive out of 15 possible changes for the randomly selected feedback group and 9 positive out of 15 in the group which received no video feedback. Binomial Test was computed on the change scores for each group on the three dependent variables. The chance associated with all the subjects in the Self-Modeling, Counseling Behavior treatment improving their probe and affect reflection scores was p = .031. Subjects without video feedback also had a p = .031 probability that all focus on client scores would change in a positive direction. Three one-way analyses of variance on the pretest scores indicated no significant initial differences between the three groups on any dependent variable.
Conclusions Subjects exposed to videotapes of themselves portraying appropriate role models appeared to learn the three counseling behaviors better than subjects in the other groups. Randomly selected feedback had a disruptive effect on subjects, who had more negative change scores than subjects who received no video feedback. . There was a possibility that the subjects' attitudes about themselves interacted with the self-viewing procedure. However, the self, behaving appropriately, seemed to provide a potent role model for individuals. Further research should compare self-modeling procedures with more traditional forms of modeling as a method to train beginning counselors in prepracticum skills. Self-modification training was suggested as a method of maintaining the learned counseling skills. Other recommendations for further research on self-modeling were made.
Thesis75b.W549.pdf
2.92 MB
Adobe PDF
cf8e75215c617f6a162893d1387dfc2f