Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Doctoral Dissertations
  5. The effects of contingent and noncontingent teacher approval on reported feelings of self-esteem
Details

The effects of contingent and noncontingent teacher approval on reported feelings of self-esteem

Date Issued
August 1975
Author(s)
Wilson, Hayden D.
Advisor(s)
Robert L. Williams
Additional Advisor(s)
Robert G. Williams
Thomas W. George
Larry DeRidder
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/63217
Abstract

Purpose

The purpose of the study was threefold:

1. To determine the effect of noncontingent teacher approval on reported feelings of self-esteem.

2. To determine the effect of contingent teacher approval on reported feelings of self-esteem.

3. To compare the effectiveness of noncontingent teacher approval and contingent teacher approval in altering reported feelings of pupil self-esteem.

Academic behavior was also monitored to determine whether changes in reported feelings of self-esteem were associated with changes in the subjects' academic functioning.

Method

Two experiments were conducted. Each experiment was composed of two treatment groups.

Experiment I. In this experiment an elementary school resource teacher administered the treatment conditions to students who had been referred to her for remediation of academic deficiencies. Subjects met two days each week for forty-five minutes per day. The study involved an ABCBA intragroup comparison with conditions C and A counterbalanced across groups during the third and fifth phases. The five experimental phases in Group A were: (1) Contingent Teacher Approval, (2) Nonapproval, (3) Noncontingent Teacher Approval, (4) Nonapproval, and (5) Contingent Teacher Approval. The order of treatment in Group B was: (1) Contingent Teacher Approval, (2) Non- Approval, (3) Contingent Teacher Approval, (4) Nonapproval, and (5) Noncontingent Teacher Approval.

Four types of assessment were utilized in both groups. They were a Smiley Face Instrument, a Short Self-Report Instrument, a Long Self- Report Instrument, and academic testing.

The Smiley Face Measure consisted of five faces ranging from very happy to very sad. Subjects were asked to "Circle the fact that shows how you feel right now." This measure was given approximately every other day throughout the study.

The Short and Long Self-Report Instruments were similar in format to each other. Both required subjects to provide "yes" or "no" answers. The short measure asked ten questions regarding the subjects' feelings toward the situation within the resource room. The long measure asked thirty-one questions dealing with situations outside of the resource room. Both were to have been given at the beginning and end of the study and at the end of each treatment phase. However, because of negative student reaction to their administration the use of both measures was discontinued prior to the end of the study.

The academic tests covered the material which the subjects had been studying. These tests were constructed by the teacher. They were administered at the end of each treatment phase.

Experiment II. This experiment was conducted during reading time in a second grade classroom. . Subjects were members of the two highest reading groups. They met for forty-five minutes each day. The design of this study was an ABCB intragroup comparison with treatment conditions C and B counterbalanced during the third and fourth phases. The treatment phases for Group A were: (1) Baseline, (2) Nonapproval, (3) Contingent Teacher Approval, and (4) Nonapproval. The treatment phases for Group B were: (1) Baseline, (2) Contingent Teacher Approval, (3) Nonapproval, and (4) Contingent Teacher Approval.

Two types of assessment instruments were utilized in both groups. They were the Smiley Face and the academic tests. All were identical in construction and administration to the measures used in Experiment I.

Results

Experiment I. Responses reflecting the most positive self-affect on the Smiley Face Instrument were given during the Contingent Teacher Approval phases of the study. The most negative responses occured during the Noncontingent Approval phase. The mean responses during the Nonapproval phases were less than during Contingent Teacher Approval but were greater than during Noncontingent Approval. These results were consistent across both groups.

The highest percentages of correct responses on the academic tests also followed the Contingent Approval phases. The lowest mean percentage followed the Nonapproval phases. These results were also consistent across both groups.

The results of the Short and Long Self-Report Measures were inconclusive. Neither individual nor group data yielded any apparent trends.

Experiment II. The responses to the Smiley Face in this experiment also reflected more positive self-affect during the Contingent Approval phases. No additional data were available concerning Noncontingent Approval.

The highest percentage of correct responses to the academic tests occured following the Nonapproval conditions. These data were consistent across both groups of this experiment. However, it was not consistent with the results of Experiment I.

Conclusions

Contingent Teacher Approval seems to result in an increase in reported feelings of self-esteem. However, Noncontingent Teacher Approval does not result in increased self-esteem on the instruments utilized in the present study.

Greater attention should be given in future studies to the choice of assessment procedures utilized to monitor the dependent variable, reported feelings of self-esteem. 1 Though there are several possible choices, the type of instrument most likely to be sensitive to the effects of the independent variable is a nonstandardized, skill specific measure. Skill specific instrumentation would focus on assessment of the subject's perceptions of his own ability with respect to specific behaviors for which approval has been administered.

Degree
Doctor of Education
Major
Educational Psychology
File(s)
Thumbnail Image
Name

Thesis75b.W548.pdf

Size

3.24 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

92b246277f87f72a677f7a3da3514814


University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science