The search for a political theory in the fiction of Herman Melville
Throughout his fiction, from Typee to Billy Budd, Herman Melville examined various methods of political organization, searching always for the best form of government possible to man. Using the device of the ship microcosm, direct depiction of political issues, and allegory, Melville analyzed traditional monarchy and American democracy, and in Moby-Dick and Billy Budd he examined other forms political states might take in the modern world. Melville objectively explored the various features of the political systems he scrutinized, so that instead of projecting a formalized political philosophy, his fictional works suggest an ongoing exploration of political alternatives. But if the question of the best form of government is not resolved in Melville's fiction, its criteria are established since he judges every political system in terms of its effect on the life of the average man and with respect to the ideals of freedom and equality inherent in the American dream.
The real significance of an awareness of the political elements of Melville's fiction is the contribution such an awareness can make to a clearer understanding both of individual works and of their relation to each other. For example, a recognition that the circumstances on the Pequod greatly resemble the conditions found in a totalitarian political system leads to a fuller comprehension of Ahab and his actions and his relationship with the mates and crew in Moby-Dick. And while the political perspective is only one of the many valid approaches that can be taken to Melville's fiction--a comprehensive view of his work necessarily involves a recognition of its complexity in several realms-- Melville's search for the best political theory that can be instituted by man provides a unifying theme for his fictional works.
Thesis75b.K356.pdf
9.95 MB
Adobe PDF
9ab4ec37551c5d7ac504bc5456082efe