The Black Lung Association : a case study of a modern social movement
Recent studies in the sociology of social movements have reflected a change in emphasis from the traditional psychological approach to more of a concern for sociological variables. This trend has been accompanied by a shift in the basic theoretical perspective from collective behavior to social organization. A new concept, the "social movement organization," has evolved out of this process. Several theorists have suggested that this social movement organization is similar to the complex, institutionalized, bureaucratic organization and can be studied within the same theoretical and conceptual framework. Others, however, observe that the modern social movement organization is not at all like a complex, institutionalized, bureaucratic structure but has a form which is decentralized, multiheaded, very segmented, and is influenced by external as well as internal forces.
The issue of the "social movement organization' has evoked considerable discussion but very little empirical data has been collected. This research is an attempt to provide intensive information about one social movement and its organization, the Black Lung Association, through a case study analysis.
This research project actually began in the fall of 1972 with the collection of initial data about the history and operation of the Black Lung Association. The process intensified in the summer of 1973 when the author moved to West Virginia to spend approximately 11 months working as a part-time participant observer with the Black Lung Association. The collection of data, however, included, in addition to direct contact, information from newspapers, government documents, old Black Lung Association files, and any other available information relevant to the existence of the movement and its organization. The collection process continued to the time of this writing.
The analysis of the data led to the following general conclusions:
1. That the bureaucratic model of organizations is not necessarily applicable to all social movement organizations. Some movement organizations are reflective of a more decentralized, multiple leadership, and segmented structure.
2. That the internal structure of movement organizations is very much influenced by external factors, and that the interaction between these elements determines the outcome of the movement.
3. That the study of social movements and their organizations is best conceptualized in a framework that identifies both dynamic and static aspects of the phenomenon.
Thesis75b.J834.pdf
16.42 MB
Adobe PDF
745a1aab3c398dbfe0260e9a07f12eca