The effects of two supervisory approaches on teacher attitude toward supervision, evaluation and self
The problem investigated in this study was that of diverse attitudes of teachers toward supervision. The main purpose of the study was to determine the effects that two different supervisory approaches had on the attitude of teachers toward supervision, evaluation and self. Specifically, the study sought to answer the following questions: (1) What effect does the supervisory approach have on the attitudes of the teachers toward supervision and administration? (2) Does the supervisory approach have an effect on the way the supervisor and the teacher analyze instruction? (3) Does the supervisory approach relate to the teacher's self-image?
The initial step was to determine characteristics, principles, and practices of both general and clinical supervision from a review of related literature. In order to obtain data concerning the three specific questions, an opinionnaire consisting of 72 items was constructed and administered to 32 secondary English teachers in the Southwest Area of the Memphis City School System. The opinionnaire contained 11 items that dealt with demographic data, 36 items for determining attitudes toward supervision and evaluation, and 25 items for the purpose of getting some idea of the respondents' self-concept. Of the 36 items designed for determining attitudes toward supervision and evaluation, 20 of them reflected assumptions and procedures of clinical supervision, and l6 of them dealt with some general aspects of supervision.
Participants in the study were divided into an experimental and a contrcl group, representing eight schools in the system. The schools were matched according to enrollment, program offerings, racial balance of students and faculty, and geographical location. Teachers were matched according to certification and years of experience. English was chosen as the vehicle for teaching, and the principals served as supervisors.
In addition to the opinionnaire, semistructured interviews were also utilized as a technique for data collecting. The ten questions for the interviews were divided into two categories: (1) "The Role of the Supervisor" and (2) "Evaluation of Teacher Performance." All questions were asked verbatim to maintain as much control over the interview as possible.
Prior to the study, a 2-day training session was conducted for the principals and teachers in the experimental group. The trainers thoroughly familiarized each participant with the methodology of clinical supervision and with the formulation and writing of instructional objectives. Procedures for the conduct of the study were explained to the teachers and administrators in the control group in a separate setting. These principals were instructed to continue to utilize their usual general supervisory approach for supervising and evaluating the teacher.
It was concluded from this study that a more positive attitude toward supervision was reflected for the experimental group, which had been exposed to a clinical supervision approach, than for the control group, which had been exposed to a general supervision approach. The responses of the two groups were more closely related on the self-concept portion of the opinionnaire.
The following recommendations were suggested as a result of this study: (1) Further research to determine how teachers and administrators tend to agree or disagree with assumptions and procedures of clinical supervision; (2) Further investigations into the aspects of supervision toward which so many of the control group teachers were negative; (3) School systems should employ and/or train supervisors who can provide assistance to teachers in analyzing, developing, and improving process skills related to effective instruction; and (4) Provisions should be made for administrative alternatives in order to give' the school principal more time and opportunity to concentrate his efforts on instructional leadership.
Thesis75b.M937.pdf
4.89 MB
Adobe PDF
382623a20b222b5a85ff2a06cbfd08f1