An analysis of the demand for bus and shared-ride taxi service in two smaller urban areas
A study was made of the demand for the publicly owned, fixed-route, fixed-schedule bus service and the privately owned, demand-responsive transportation service in two smaller urban areas--Davenport, Iowa, and Hicksville, New York. The demand-responsive transportation systems were innovative taxicab enterprises which, in their manner of operation, resembled many of the current publicly owned dial-a-ride systems; that is, the taxi systems provided on-call, door-to-door public transportation on a shared-ride basis, pooling unrelated trips into the same cab when practicable by deviating the vehicle from the direct route. The objectives of the study were to compare the travel patterns and markets of the bus and shared-ride taxi systems, to compare the travel patterns and markets of the shared-ride taxi system in each study area, to analyze the factors and circumstances underlying the choice of either the bus or the shared-ride taxi, and to measure the public sentiment toward each form of public transportation.
Several sources of data were utilized in the study. Information on the usage of the bus and shared-ride taxi systems was gathered through onboard surveys, mail surveys, and home interviews. Additional information on the characteristics of the demand for shared-ride taxi service was provided by dispatching records and drivers' logs maintained by the two taxicab companies. Finally, the users as well as the non-users of public transportation were interviewed in their homes to determine their attitudes toward each mode of public transportation.
In many respects, the bus and shared-ride taxi systems were competitive. Both forms of public carriage attracted similar types of people. Except for the movement of masses of commuters during the peak hours, the two modes also performed many of the same functions although not to the same degree. The shared-ride taxis, for example, were particularly useful for trips between widely scattered origins and destinations. The shared-ride taxi system in Hicksville provided an important feeder service to the Long Island Railroad commuter rail network. The bus was usually chosen because of its lower fare by persons who were generally more dependent upon public transportation. The shared-ride cab, on the other hand, was selected for reasons related to its flexibility of movement and door-to-door service by persons with virtually the same socioeconomic characteristics as the bus users. The bus system was generally regarded as the more important mode; however, there was no consensus among nonusers of public transportation that the bus service should be subsidized and publicly owned. On the other hand, it was strongly felt by the public that the financing and provision of taxicab service was strictly the responsibility of private enterprise. Nevertheless, in communities with a population less than at least 100,000 and possibly up to 250,000, local planners and policy makers should consider a shared-ride taxi system or some other variation of a privately owned demand-responsive transportation system as a replacement for fixed-route, fixed-schedule bus service during off-peak periods.
Thesis75b.M533.pdf
10.73 MB
Adobe PDF
d230fb6d95dc01d3347547bd567b5a1d