Effectiveness of programmed theory remedial instruction in Gregg Diamond Jubilee Shorthand
The problem of this study was to determine the effectiveness of Programmed Remedial Shorthand Booklets as remedial instruction when used to teach selected Gregg Diamond Jubilee Shorthand principles to students in selected post-secondary schools.
Four programmed booklets were written by the researcher using 16 of the most frequently missed principles in Gregg Diamond Jubilee Shorthand. Each programmed booklet emphasized four principles:
Program I--ings, ng, rity, lity-lty
Program II--ther, ort, ern-erm, ition-ation Program
III--ulate, ul, den-ten, dev-def
Program IV--super, for-fore-fur, m-n or m-m,
inter-intr-enter-entr.
The programs used words which were listed beyond the first 5,000 words in Mellinger's Basic Vocabulary for Written Office Communications. When too few words appeared in the Mellinger list to include in the programmed booklets, the Normal and Reverse English Word List was used.
Alternate forms of the word list and dictation pretests, posttests, and retention tests were prepared and equated. Tests were based on the first 5,000 words of the Mellinger list and used some words beyond the first 5,000 when needed.
The sample consisted of second-, third-, or fourth-quarter or second-semester shorthand students enrolled in Gregg Diamond Jubilee Shorthand classes in post-secondary institutions in Tennessee, Kentucky, or North Carolina. Students in the shorthand classes were matched with students in the same class on the basis of achievement on combined word list and dictation pretest scores. For a matched pair, one student was placed in an experimental group; the matching student was placed in a control group. Experimental students in shorthand classes completed one of the Programmed Remedial Shorthand Booklets outside of class; control students in shorthand classes received no additional remedial instruction. Both experimental and control students were administered the word list and dictation post-test immediately after the experimental students completed the programs. Students were administered the word list and dictation retention test three weeks after the pretests.
The nonparametric Wilcoxon Matched-Pairs Signed-Ranks test was used at the .O1 level for all comparisons of pre-, post-, and retentiontests for all groups. The Spearman Rank Correlation technique was used to determine (1) correlations of pretests, post-tests, and retention tests, and (2) correlation of time to combined word list and dictation post-test and retention test scores.
The major findings of the study were:
1. Combined word list and dictation pretest scores were not significantly different except for Program IV, which had significantly higher pretest scores for the control group than for the experimental group. For all four programs, combined word list and dictation posttest and retention test scores for experimental students were significantly higher than the scores for the control students except the retention test scores for Program II.
2. On the basis of individual word list post-test and retention test scores, all four programs had a significant immediate effect on students' word list test performance. Program IV was the only program having a retention effect on students' word list test performance.
3. On the basis of individual dictation post-test and retention test scores, Programs II and IV had a significant immediate effect on students' dictation test performance. None of the four programs had a significant retention effect on students' dictation test performance.
4. For word list test gain scores, experimental students' immediate performance was significantly higher than that of control students on all four programs. For retention performance, students completing Programs III and IV had significantly higher scores than the control students.
5. For dictation test gain scores, experimental students' immediate performance was significantly higher than that of control students on Programs I and II. For retention performance, students completing Programs I, II, and III had significantly higher scores than the control students.
6. Correlation coefficients for the four programs indicated that no matter what the treatment, the tests were significantly related. Time spent completing the programs did not significantly affect students' performance on post-tests or retention tests for Programs I, II, III, and IV.
Thesis75b.C643.pdf
6.99 MB
Adobe PDF
4d0e2193bebbbab2246961e14c7b262f