Aux armes Citayens! The National Guard in the Paris Commune of 1871
The Paris Commune of 1871 has long been a controversial subject for both historians and theorists of revolution. This thesis examines the Commune "from the bottom up," through a study of the National Guard, in order to strip away some of the mythology surrounding the seventy-two days of the revolution. Direct democracy, the most important principle in theory and in action for the Federated National Guard of 1871, provides the key to understanding the Commune. Direct, participatory democracy permeated every level of activity within the Commune, but its impetus came from the population of revolutionary Paris, not from leaders or the decrees of the communal council.
Perhaps mcre so than any other revolution, the Commune must be studied "from the bottom up." It began spontaneously and its first leaders, the members of the Central Committee of the National Guard, took power almost by default, considering it their duty to follow, not to lead. The communal council elected on 26 March inherited a still-undefined new society that had to defend itself in an increasingly bitter civil war. Although they did not know it, the Commune was foredoomed: if it had not fallen to the regular French government, it would have succumbed to the Prussian troops still occupying northern France. For two: months the communal council divided its time between attempts to define the new society and efforts to wage war -- and in the process the gap between its debates and the life of revolutionary Paris widened. No single man or group emerged to mold the revolution in its early days, and by the time the "Jacobin majority" asserted itself at the beginning of May, the real life of the Commune was located elsewhere -- on the streets, in the clubs, above all in the ranks of the National Guard.
The National Guard, the citizen army whose Central Committee presided over the beginning of the revolution, serves as the focus for a study of the popular base of the Commune because its ranks included almost all male citizens and some of the female citizens of Paris. Increased in size during the Franco-Prussian War of 1870, the Parisian Guard organized itself into a Federation in February 1871, and its actions and services touched nearly every aspect of life in the city. From the beginning direct democracy constituted the basic principle of the Federation, and the revolution of 18 March only strengthened Guardsmen's adherence to the principle. Every attempt by the Commune's generals to compromise direct democracy for the sake of military efficiency met with stubborn opposition and outright refusal to comply. from the ranks. The result was an army far more citizen than soldier, often inefficient, unreliable, and chaotic. But it was democratic, and it held off government troops far longer than expected. The Federation of the National Guard perished with the Commune, but its members had the sense to sce what later revolutionaries often ignored: the way the revolution is fought will determine the form of the new society.
Thesis75b.C462.pdf
18.74 MB
Adobe PDF
38c754085eb78f1a9e0d082c709eb395