A study of relationships between personality categories and death concern in a selected group of nurses
Death is a universal, personal experience. Every individual confronts death at some time in his life, but for some people, such as health personnel, this confrontation is more frequent. It is one of the "occupational hazards" involved in the profession. This study was concerned with one particular segment of health personnel, namely registered nurses and student nurses. This group is faced with particularly difficult problems in coping with dying patients.
The nurse, more than any other member of a hospital staff, faces the dying patient on a continuing basis from the first admission, to the witnessing of death, to the call to the mortuary. The boundaries and finitude of life and the inevitability of death are parts of life to which she often bears witness. But in most cases the nurse is not prepared to cope with the dying patient effectively, despite the fact that it is she who must maintain the closest contact with him.
The primary purpose of this study was to investigate the relationship between personality traits and attitudes toward death of those who care for the dying. More specific answers to the following questions were sought: (a) Do attitudes toward death change as a person confronts death more often, beginning with the student nurse and ending with the practicing, experienced, registered nurse? (b) Do certain nursing personality types show more or less concern toward death?
The sample population for this study consisted of 60 student nurses who were completing their first, second, and third years of nursing training and 25 registered nurses whose experience ranged from one year to 33 years. All of the subjects answered two questionnaires. The Dickstein Death Concern Scale measured death concern, and the Personal Orientation Inventory measured values and behavior.
Two methods of statistical analysis were employed to examine the data derived from the Personal Orientation Inventory and the Dickstein Death Concern Scale. These methods were the Kruskal-Wallis One-Way Analysis-of-Variance Test and the Mann-Whitney U Test. The Kruskal- Wallis One-Way Analysis-of-Variance Test was applicable when the investigator was concerned with the significance of difference between samples ranked according to some ordinal characteristic. Scores on the particular ordinal-level characteristic were ranked within the samples, and the Kruskal-Wallis Test determined whether or not there were differences between the samples with regard to their ranks. The Mann- Whitney U Test determined the significance of the difference between two samples where the samples had been ranked according to an ordinal-level variable. More specifically, it indicated the distribution of high and low ranks with regard to the measured characteristic under consideration.
On the basis of the data compiled, the investigator concluded that there was a significant relationship between several personality traits and death concern. However, the differences with regard to these traits were not found across groups. The personality traits that differed at the P ≤ O.05 level of confidence were time incompetence and time competence for the registered nurses, and inner-directed and other-directed traits and self-acceptance for the second year student nurses. The investigator also found that there was a significant difference in the death concern of registered nurses and second year student nurses and in the death concern of registered nurses and third year student nurses. No significant difference appeared in relationship to the number of deaths experienced and the degree of death concern. While the number of deaths experienced ranged from zero to 45 in the 'sample population, the death concern exhibited did not vary significantly with regard to that number.
Before more definitive conclusions about death can be drawn, more systematic observation of death'and the responses it elicits is necessary. Our knowledge of death and attitudes toward death are still largely theoretical at this point. Conclusions drawn from studies such as the present one point to starting places for this essential observation.
Thesis75b.G242.pdf
13.32 MB
Adobe PDF
a1ae41b906e5190f3d9d15365d76d11f