A systems engineering analysis
Very often a traffic safety improvement project is disapproved because the administrators aren't sure that the improvement will reduce accidents and is cost effective.
This study shows a systems engineering analysis approach to traffic safety problems that can be used by any traffic planning group to plan and program safety improvements based on forecasted accident reductions and cost effectiveness.
The study was conducted on a large U.S. Air Force base and consisted of traffic volume counts, capacity analysis of the major signalized intersections, traffic accident analysis, an origin-destination study, and a traffic oriented data system.
The major part of the study involved the traffic accident analysis. Traffic accident information were coded and a computer program written to break out the accident data by location of occurrence. These data were then used in a statistical test, the rate quality-control test, to determine hazardous locations. The test assured at the 0.90 probability level that the hazardous location was not hazardous by chance. Once knowing where the hazardous locations were and the condition of all the accidents that occurred there, remedial improvements were selected. Each improvement selected had a corresponding accident reduction probability. These probabilities along with the direct cost of accidents were used to determine the cost effectiveness of the selected improvements. In the cost analysis, benefit-to-cost ratios were calculated. The benefit used was the total annual dollar savings based on the expected accident reduction given an improvement. The cost used was the total annual cost of the improvement including the time value of money. The hazardous locations were then ranked by benefit-to-cost ratios to determine the order of making the improvements. This analysis showed that the main roadway on the base should be upgraded from a three lane, center reversible lane highway to a four lane, median divided highway with left turn lanes at the major intersections. The recommended improvements were shown to more than pay for themselves in lower costs due to accident reductions.
Intersection capacity analysis showed that two of five intersections analyzed required major construction in order to relieve traffic congestion.
Origin-destination data showed that the major driver irritants were too few parking places and too few traffic lanes on the main roadway of the base.
The data system used as a data base information obtained from vehicle registration forms administered by the base Air Police. When the regulation governing the registration of vehicles was changed and registration was no longer required, the data system was abandoned since the data base no longer existed.
Thesis74.E443.pdf
10.32 MB
Adobe PDF
b4096120c21ba21050bb0240af29b979