Determining the degree of objectivity in the judging of the gymnastic vaulting event by a cinematographic analysis
This study was concerned with the objectivity in the judging of the vaulting event. The scoring evaluation recorded by a panel of four judges were correlated with film evaluations determined through a cinematographic analysis of the handspring vault.
The data were compiled from the judges' numerical ratings during the vaulting competition and the numerical film ratings of the same handspring vault. The film ratings were determined using the scoring criteria provided by the International Gymmastic Federation Code of Points.
Each of the film ratings for the six evaluation categories was correlated with the judges' average rating for the same categories. The final film score was also correlated with the judges' final score. Correlations between each judge and the average rating of all the judges were found in each of the six categories.
The findings revealed the only significant correlation between the judges' average rating and film rating to be the preflight category. Two of the individual judges' revealed low correlations to the average preflight category, repulsion category and afterflight category.
Thesis74.E393.pdf
1.59 MB
Adobe PDF
aa5766d25d98141aced5a87d3d2ae8a8