The effects of grammatical class, phoneme difficulty and phoneme position upon error productions of apraxic speakers
This study investigated the effects of grammatical class, phoneme difficulty and phoneme position on the speech production of apraxic speakers during a spontaneous speech task.
Ten subjects with apraxia of speech as their primary communication disorder were selected. All met the following selection criteria: : at least three months post brain trauma; normal hearing acuity in the better ear at 500, 1,000 and 2,000 Hz; and no significant receptive difficulties as demonstrated by their ability to pass ten selected items from the Revised Token Test (McNeil, 1973).
Two stimulus word lists were presented. List I included equal numbers of nouns, verbs and adjectives, each of which included one of six phonemes judged to be difficult for apraxic speakers to produce. Each of the six phonemes in List I appeared equally in the initial and final position of the stimulus words listed. Each grammatical category, therefore, contained a given phoneme in four words, two with the phoneme in the initial position and two with the phoneme in the final position. List II was similarly constructed but contained words in which the six test phonemes were judged as easy for apraxic speakers to produce. Each stimulus word was presented in a sentence which was read to the subject twice. In the first reading the sentence was read in its entirety; during the second reading the stimulus word was left out. It was the subjects' task to provide orally the missing word. The subjects' word productions were judged twice, once to evaluate the test phoneme and once to evaluate the entire word.
Statistical analyses of subject error scores revealed that the apraxic speakers, as a group, incorrectly produced difficult phonemes and words containing difficult phonemes significantly more often than easy phonemes and words containing these easy phonemes. However, the grammatical class of the word and the position of the test phoneme in the stimulus word did not significantly effect the apraxic speakers production of these words or phonemes. Subjects x difficulty and subjects x position interactions were found to be significant for both phoneme and word evaluations. No other two or three way interactions were significant. The results of the interaction analyses suggest that the performances of apraxic speakers are differentially effected both at the phoneme and word level when stimuli differ in regard to the position of the phoneme in a stimulus word and the judged difficulty of the test phoneme.
Thesis74.D854.pdf
2.32 MB
Adobe PDF
53cd6e067f072f547c9abc99aab386db