A study of the development of selected leadership behaviors in vocational EPDA Programs
The main purpose of this study was to provide some partial assessment information regarding the effectiveness of the Vocational Education EPDA doctoral programs in developing leadership capable of bringing about reform and giving direction to the field of vocational education. A questionnaire technique was used with the department chairpersons at the 18 institutions having EPDA doctoral programs in vocational education and the 287 individuals who received EPDA doctoral fellowship awards between 1970 and 1972. Two hundred and fifty-six students (89 percent) and 18 department chairpersons (100 percent) responded to the questionnaire.
The major objectives of the study were to (1) assess EPDA graduate students' and department chairpersons' perceptions regarding the importance of selected leadership behaviors and the opportunities for developing those behaviors during the doctoral programs and (2) to assess the EPDA fellows' perceptions regarding their growth in the selected leadership skills as a result of their doctoral programs.
Specifically the study attempted to answer the following questions:
1. Did students and department chairpersons share similar views about the importance of the selected leadership behaviors?
2. Did students perceive themselves as increasing their leadership skills while in the programs?
3. To what extent did vocational education departments provide experiences and promote growth in the selected leadership behaviors?
4. What experiences did department chairpersons identify in the EPDA doctoral programs at their respective institutions that foster student growth in the leadership competencies identified for this study?
5. What experiences did students perceive that they had had during their doctoral programs at their respective institutions that actually contributed to their perceived growth in the selected leadership competencies?
From the literature on change, leadership and organizational development the following leadership behaviors were identified as being essential to a leader functioning as a change agent:
1. Confronting and managing conflict.
2. Sharing decision making responsibilities with others.
3. Developing a group into a team to focus on solving problems.
4. Understanding yourself.
5. Being sensitive to value systems different to your own.
6. Seeing how things appear from another person's point of view.
7. Adapting to change and innovation.
8. Being able to identify a number of alternatives as solutions to a problem.
Being able to foresee the consequences of various alternative solutions to a problem.
The study showed that department chairpersons and students overwhelmingly agree that the functional leadership skills identified for this study are important skills to be developed by people in vocational education leadership positions.
Moreover, a large majority of students believe that they made extensive or some growth in the nine functional leadership skills. Thus the EPDA doctoral programs appear to be doing a good job in promoting growth in this group of selected leadership behaviors. However, a noteable number of students perceived little or no growth or felt uncertain about increasing their competency in the selected behaviors.
The strengths of the EPDA doctoral programs appear to be found in promoting growth in those behaviors which are predominately cognitive and structure oriented in nature, for example, (1) Adapting to change and innovation and (2) Identifying alternatives and consequences. The EPDA programs appear to be somewhat less successful in promoting growth in those skills which are more strongly human relations oriented, for example, (1) Confronting and managing conflict and (2) Understanding yourself.
Experiences provided through vocational education Courses, Professors and Internships appear to be doing a particularly good job in providing for student growth in the following areas: (1) Adapting to change and innovation, (2) Foreseeing consequences, (3) Developing teams, and (4) Sharing decision making responsibilities with others.
Thesis75b.B852.pdf
14.06 MB
Adobe PDF
c860f5d9bf927ac4d713e28feef4b5e3