The effects of participation in collaborative supervision upon cooperating teacher's job satisfaction and upon their evaluation of fellow teachers, student teachers, and supervisors as sources of new instructional ideas
The purpose of this investigation was to determine the effects of participation in collaborative supervision on cooperating teachers' job satisfaction and upon their evaluation of fellow teachers, student teachers, and supervisors as sources of new instructional ideas.
The subjects were a randomly-selected group of 44 student teachers and the 44 cooperating teachers to whom they had been assigned for student teaching for the spring quarter, 1974, at The University of Tennessee, Knoxville. Subjects were randomly assigned to experimental and control groups. The basic research design was a simple parallel groups design with pretests and posttests. Treatment for the experimental group consisted of (1) eight three-hour training sessions in collaborative supervision skills and concepts during the winter quarter preceding the spring quarter student teaching, (2) 10 weeks of participation in collaborative supervision during the spring quarter, and (3) two review and evaluation sessions during the spring quarter. Subjects functioned as members of collaborative teams consisting of equal numbers of student teachers and cooperating teachers.
Two instruments--the Purdue Teacher Opinionnaire, developed by Ralph Bentley and Averno Rempel, and a semantic differential instrument consisting of three concepts constructed by the investigator according to the techniques of Osgood--were used to test the following hypotheses at the .05 level of significance:
1. There will be no significant difference between pre- and posttest scores of experimental and cooperating teachers' attitudes toward their work as measured by the Purdue Teacher Opinionnaire.
2. There is no significant difference between experimental cooperating teachers' and control cooperating teachers' evaluation of student teachers as a source of new educational ideas.
3. There is no significant difference between experimental cooperating teachers' evaluation of fellow teachers as a source of new educational ideas.
4. There is no significant difference between experimental cooperteachers' evaluation of supervisors as a source of new instructional ideas.
The data were analyzed by a one-way analysis of variance with a resulting F-score.
The following were the major findings:
1. The first hypotheses was rejected. There was a statistically significant improvement in cooperating teachers' job satisfaction.
2. The second hypothesis was not rejected. There was no evidence that participation in collaborative supervision increased cooperating teachers' evaluation of fellow teachers as a source of new instructional ideas.
3. The third hypothesis was not rejected, There was no evidence that participation in collaborative supervision increased cooperating teachers' evaluation of student teachers as sources of,new instructional ideas.
4. The fourth hypothesis was not rejected. There was no evidence that participation in collaborative supervision increased cooperating teachers' evaluation of supervisors as sources of new instructional ideas.
In summary, the study indicated that participation in collaborative supervision caused significantly greater gains in cooperating teachers' positive attitudes to their jobs. Cooperating teachers' evaluation of fellow teachers, student teachers, and supervisors as sources of new instructional ideas was statisically significantly effected by participation in collaborative supervision.
Thesis75b.E275.pdf
3.44 MB
Adobe PDF
74e227675ab0fcb6a9b54d89cb4d5eec