Alternative plans for providing insurance protection for the physical property of the school systems of the Upper East Tennessee Educational Cooperative
The purpose of the study was to develop alternatives for providing insurance protection for physical property owned by the school districts which comprise the Upper East Tennessee Educational Cooperative. Further, the study included:
1. A review of self-insurance plans currently in operation.
2. An examination of current practices for providing insurance protection for physical property and contents.
3. A development of alternatives for the insuring of property owned by the school systems of the Upper East Tennessee Educational Cooperative.
4. The development of bid specifications for the requesting of competitive bids.
5. Conclusions and recommendations based on the findings of the study.
The study was limited to the 13 school systems which make up the Upper East Tennessee Educational Cooperative with data collected concerning the past cost and claims of those school systems including the twenty-year period 1954-55 to 1973-74. The study examined present purchasing practices, cooperative purchasing, and a combination of partial self-insurance and cooperative purchasing for insurance on real property and contents only.
Partial self-insurance implies the purchase of commercial insurance with a deductible amount. Therc are two methods of specifying deductible limits: per occurrence and aggregate annual. Per occurrence means that for every insured loss the deductible must be met and aggregate annual means that after the total losses for any one year exceed the agreed amount, the commercial insurance begins to assume the risk. This type of deductible improves the predictability of the program and was used in developing the alternatives.
The purchase of deductible insurance should be accompanied by the establishment of funds to cover losses not in excess of the deductible. The critical issue in the creation of any self-insurance fund is the establishment of the reserve fund. The basis for the fund is the annual contribution to the fund. These contributions would be the difference in the premium of the full coverage protection and the deductible coverage. The fund may be initiated by the use of these funds only. However, in the beginning, they will not equal the deductible limits, and, should a loss occur equal to that limit, an additional appropriation would have to be made. The recommended method for starting a fund is with an appropriation, preferably equal to twice the amount of the deductible limits. In addition to the deductible commercial insurance, each school system should assume an aggregate annual deductible of $1,000 before making claims against the fund.
The bid specifications ask for bids with $5,000, $10,000, $25,000, $50,000, and $75,000 deductibles. A review of past experiences would indicate that for a successful fund to be established in connection with each of these, the following savings would have to be achieved over the purchase of full coverage insurance: $5,000 - 2.8 percent; $10,000 4.22 percent; $25,000 - 7.7 percent; $50,000 - 13 percent; and $75,000 17.3 percent.
Based on these options, alternatives were developed which would provide for the initiation of a cooperative insurance program with the election of a board of trustees to advertise for bids and recommend a cooperative policy. It is recommended that a fund be established with each contributing in the same percentage as the amount of premiums paid. After a school system has losses of $1,000 in any one year, additional losses will be covered by the fund up to the deductible limits; losses would then be covered by commercial insurance. Should the fund, at the end of any one year, exceed four times the amount of the deductible limit, the difference in the cost of full coverage and the deductible premium should be returned to the school system, and any money earned by the fund should also be returned to the school system. An alternative is to allow the fund to continue to grow and increase the deductible limits in an attempt to achieve greater savings.
Thesis75b.D888.pdf
7.69 MB
Adobe PDF
88e581a8d61aa07e93394f1e90f07632