An electrical analysis of an electrostatic precipitator with emphasis on stability
The purpose of this research was to study the Carrier Corporation Light Components Department ionizer with special regard to the stability of the ionizer wires. The basic problem was to study why the ionizer wires vibrated. This unstable condition could lead to arc-over from the wire to the precipitator ground plate and consequently could cause possible power supply damage or wire damage.
The analysis consisted of coordinated theoretical and experimental work. To a considerable degree, the theoretical analysis was done by Marshall O. Pace, while the experimental analysis was done by the author. Also, Dr. Igor Alexeff contributed considerable work on the parallel RC circuit model for the dust.
The Carrier L.C.D. ionizer is simply a rectangular array of 14 ground plates of dimensions 0.4826 by 0.6604 meters with 13 ionizer wires in between them, equally spaced apart. An equivalent electrical circuit for the single wire, double plate system was made of a typical ionizer unit from the Carrier L.C.D. plant. From this circuit, a block diagram system model was then made.
Experimental measurements were made using a single wire, double plate model such that the wire-to-plate spacing and the wire tension could be varied easily. The parameters in the block diagram system were then measured over a large range in the system variables.
Two independent computer programs were used to compare the theoretical and experimental models. In this way, the accuracy of the theory was able to be verified.
The basic mechanism of this wire oscillation can be explained as the following. If the ionizer wire is ever closer to one plate than the other, more current is drawn to the closer plate, charging up that layer of dust to a potential of the sign of the potential of the wire. The Coulomb force of like charges pushes the wire from the closer plate toward the further plate. This push-pull effect continues adding kinetic energy into the wire until the amplitude of oscillation is limited or arc-over takes place. Thus, the oscillation grows if electrical energy is transmitted to the wire as mechanical energy from air drag damping effects and friction.
A simplification of the block diagram system provided a characteristic equation and consequently a stringent stability criterion. Reasonable engineering approximations reduced this strict criterion to a much simpler criterion which involves only the nature of the dust, the air drag on the wire, and the coupling parameters of the block diagram system.
In conclusion, by altering certain precipitator parameters, this simple criterion may be used to alter precipitator designs such that wire oscillation is impossible.
Thesis74.C6644.pdf
4.64 MB
Adobe PDF
3d9a7b26a154fa28ea01ed2592820837