A comparative study of breeding-bird populations on two strip-mined areas
A breeding-bird census was undertaken to Hurricane Mountain in Campbell County, Tennessee, in order to make a comparison of the bird populations between an area disturbed by a strip mine of recent origin and an area censused by Richard H. Yahner, where strip mining has taken place twenty years ago. Yahner carried out censuses in both 1972 and 1973. Comparisons in this study are with the results he obtained in 1973. The present study consisted of 56 acres on which a grid pattern of one-acre units was imposed.
The area was chosen to meet the criteria of being geographically close and physically similar to the area censused by Yahner. A botanical description of the area included the results obtained by using the 0.1 acre circle method in the forested regions. The study area was divided into five habitats: a Strip Mine Area, a Spoils Area, an Openings Area, a Marginal Area, and a Forest Area. The area was censused with twelve complete coverages of the plot. Utilization indexes, devised by Yahner, were used to determine which habitats were most frequently utilized by the breeding species on the plot and to compare results with the same indexes found by Yahner. Utilization indexes were based on the percentage of the total number of contacts per 100 acres in each of the habitat divisions. Species richness and frequncy of utilization by all species were determined for each habitat division and both were compared to the values which Yahner found. Species richness was simply the number of species in each habitat division for which at least one single male contact was recorded. Frequency of utilization was the total number of all contacts for all species in each habitat division.
The number of breeding-bird territories on the census area was 158.5. Population density was calculated to be 283 pairs of breeding brids per 100 acres. Yahner found a density of 341 pairs per 100 acres in 1973.
Species were classified according to which habitats they utilized at least 75 percent of the time, based on the utilization indexes. One less species was calssified as a Strip Mine Area species than the number of species which Yahner classified as Strip Mine Area species. There was one less Marginal Area species and one more Forest Area species than Yahner found in his census. The number of Openings Area species was 24, while Yahner calculated only 10 for his area. Only 6 species utilized the Spoils Area, and this compares to 24 species which utilized the spoils Area on Yahner's plot.
Species richness was greatest in the Forest Area (34 species) and the Marginal Area (33 species). The Openings Area had 24 species, while the Strip Mine and Spoils Area had 18 and 22 species, respectively. This compares to Yahner's 1973 results of: 29 species in the Forest Area, 33 species in the Marginal Area, 14 species in the Openings Area, 27 species in the Spoils Area, and the 13 species in the Strip Mine Area.
Frequency of utilization showed results that were nearly proportional to those found by Yahner except in the Spoils Area. Yahner found a frequency of utlilization for the Spoils Area that was 46.1 percent higher than the Forest Area on his plot, while the present study found a frequency of utilization for the Spoils Area that was only 75.1 percent of that found for the Forest Area.
In conclusion, it can be said that the bird populations in this recently strip-mined area were similar to those which were found by Yahner in an area that was stripped twenty years ago; but the Spoils Area on Yahner's plot offered a less severe habitat which was more frequently utilized than the Spoils Area on the present study plot. Differences were also noted between the Openings Areas, but these openings had not been created as a result of strip mining. Finally, the Strip Mine Areas showed similar avifaunal charactersitcs, which mights indicate that twenty years produce little change in the niches which are exploited by birds on an abandoned strip mine.
Thesis74.G3786.pdf
19.67 MB
Adobe PDF
09ee9de712726a2afc6041ad0f77a7cb