The development of musical understanding in the high school performance-oriented choral class
This study proposed to develop a program of instruction that would develop musical understanding in the performance-oriented choral class. The study was conducted to determine if such a program would have a significant effect on musical development, and to produce empirical evidence that the most positive musical outcomes are realized with a study utilizing a workbook, verbal instruction, and actual performance of the choral score.
To determine the effectiveness of the study a random selection of students was made in the two secondary performance-oriented choral classes of Morristown, Tennessee. The experimental group, Group A, was enrolled in the choral class of Morristown-Hamblen High School East, and the control group, Group B, was enrolled in the choral class of Morristown-Hamblen High School West.
A testing instrument which consisted of four parts was designed to evaluate the study. Part I was to measure aural-visual recognition of rhythm patterns. Part II was designed to measure aural-visual recognition of pitch and melody patterns. Part III was designed to measure knowledge of the structure and style of music. Part IV was designed to measure knowledge of the history and literature of music. The hypothesis for each part, as well as for the total mean score, was as follows: A significant difference at the 0.05 level of confidence will exist between the posttest scores of the experimental and control groups. The null hypothesis for each part, as well as the total mean score, was that a significant difference at the 0.05 level of confidence would not exist between the posttest scores of the experimental and control groups. Both groups were administered a pretest and posttest; however, since there was random selection of all sample subjects, only posttest results were used for evaluation of the study.
The statistical analysis in the study was the t test with fortyeight degrees of freedom. A t value of 2.02 or higher was necessary for a significant difference at the 0.05 level of confidence. When the two groups were compared according to aural-visual recognition of rhythm patterns the computed t value was 2.45. When the two groups were compared according to aural-visual recognition of pitch and melody the computed t value was 1.80. When the two groups were compared according to their knowledge of music structure and styles the computed t value was 2.95. When the two groups were compared according to their knowledge of music history and literature the computed t value was 4.34. When the two groups were compared according to the combined total mean scores of the test the computed t value was 3.44.
Therefore, the above scores refute the null hypothesis and support the alternate hypothesis in the areas of aural-visual recognition of rhythm patterns, music structure and styles, music history and literature, and the total mean scores of the posttest. The scores for aural-visual recognition of pitch and melody refute the alternate hypothesis and support the null hypothesis.
Based on the results of this study the conclusion was made that musical understanding can be taught in a performance-oriented choral class and that it will encourage students to improve performance skills through a better understanding of music. In four of the five test A scores, empirical evidence was produced to show that positive results can be achieved by instruction toward musical understanding instead of mere teaching by rote.
Thesis74.A335.pdf
5.62 MB
Adobe PDF
f65f66268755edec7659a5cc7f7fd2d4