A methodology for evaluating the effectiveness of highway safety program standards
This investigation searched for evaluation techniques applicable to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration's 18 Highway Safety Program Standards. The problem was attacked from the viewpoint that much can be learned from evaluation principles used in other public social action programs.
An extensive review of literature was conducted on the subjects of evaluation, evaluative research, countermeasures, measures of effectiveness, and methodologies of accident prevention to provide a broad base for the selection of evaluation techniques for optimization of highway safety program standards.
Evaluation techniques based upon this review of literature were used to critique the evaluation procedures as set out in the Final Report on Criteria for Program Evaluation--Highway Safety Standards by William A. Goodwin, submitted to the Highway Safety Planning Division, Office of Urban and Federal Affairs, State of Tennessee.
Levels I and II of Goodwin's program review were found to be adequate and feasible. Level III needed a more detailed set of criteria established on more finite measurements of effectiveness. Recommendations were made to expand this level of evaluation. A general model was proposed for Level III, encompassing four dimensions for establishing criteria of process. Examples of each dimensional model were given to show their application to selected highway safety program standards.
Thesis75.R234.pdf
2.51 MB
Adobe PDF
087d669e9105e90c71918867e65a0b8d