Comparison of measured and theoretical stresses in a simple span bridge
The purpose of this study was to compare the measured and theoretical stresses in a simple-span highway bridge and to work toward establishing a methcd to predict the number of stress fatigue cycles in a bridge girder.
Two highway bridges, part of the interstate system, were selected and instrumented for the collection of data. A Raytheon 703 computer with a magnetic tape unit, housed in a trailer, was used for the collection of stress data which was stored on magnetic tapes. Data concerning the classification of trucks was taken at the bridge site and at an official weigh station. Several controlled load tests, using a truck of known weight and axle spacing, were also conducted. The field stress data was separated into truck types, and histograms of the girder stresses were formed for each type. A finite element model of the bridge was used to formulate equations to predict the theoretical stress caused by a truck on the bridge. A Monte Carlo simulation using randcm numbers to select weights and spacings from their respective distributions was used to generate theoretical stress histograms for 3S2 and 2D trucks. The histograms of the measured and theoretical girder stresses were then compared for the two truck types.
It was found that the two stress histograms for 3S2 trucks did not compare favorably. The measured and actual stress histograms for 2D trucks were very similar. Because of the wide variation between theoretical stresses and the stresses from the controlled load tests, no attempt was made to draw any conclusions from the comparison of the stress histograms. Further research was suggested to obtain a one truck-one stress-one weight relationship in order to get a better comparison between measured and theoretical stress distributions. Once these distributions compare favorably, a method is available to predict, the number of stress fatigue cycles in bridge girders.
Thesis75.P279.pdf
3.96 MB
Adobe PDF
ad1e7641732adf4c0fd930ae1b5d0b20