A DISCOURSE-HISORICAL ANALYSIS OF JOURNALISTIC COVERAGE OF PGA TOUR, INC. V. MARTIN (2001) AND THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT IN U.S. MEN’S PROFESSIONAL GOLF, 1997-2023
Date Issued
August 2026
Author(s)
Misra, Aman
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Amber Roessner
Additional Advisor(s)
Erin Whiteside
Guy Harrison
Adam Love
Abstract
This dissertation examines how journalistic discourse has shaped public understandings of disability, access, and inclusion in U.S. men’s professional golf through coverage of PGA Tour, Inc. v. Martin (2001), the landmark Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) Supreme Court case involving professional golfer Casey Martin. It analyzes how journalistic and institutional texts have framed the case over time, including coverage of the litigation (1997–2001), its aftermath (2002-2010), and later retrospective and anniversary references (2011–2023).
Grounded in critical disability studies, Foucauldian theories of power and knowledge, and collective memory scholarship, the dissertation investigates how journalistic narratives have constructed, reinforced, or challenged ableist norms governing access, accommodation, and legitimacy within U.S. professional golf. Using the discourse-historical approach to Critical Discourse Analysis, the study examines institutional, national, local, and sport-specialty journalism to trace how legal arguments, biography, and memory have been utilized to negotiate the meaning of disability in professional sport.
Analysis demonstrates that while early coverage often depicted the ADA case as a threat to competitive integrity and institutional authority, later journalism translated the case into apolitical biography or shorthand, limiting debates around structural questions of access and inclusion. Across outlets, disability is individualized, while institutional power and exclusionary norms remain largely unexamined. By focusing on a non-Paralympic, mainstream professional sport, this dissertation extends disability sport media scholarship beyond study of elite adaptive competition. It also contributes to public memory studies by showing how silences and anniversary coverage shape memory of disability rights litigation. Finally, the study demonstrates the methodological value of discourse-historical analysis (DHA) of critical discourse analysis (CDA) in examining how law, journalism, and sport intersect to reproduce ableist power structures over time.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Journalism and Electronic Media
Embargo Date
August 1, 2032