Can Immigration Rescue a White-tailed Deer Population From CWD-induced Declines? A Summary of Tennessee’s Endemic Area
Date Issued
August 2026
Author(s)
Wyrick, Jacob
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Lisa Muller
Additional Advisor(s)
Mark Wilber
Abstract
During 2021–2025, the Tennessee Wildlife Resources Agency conducted fixed-wing, thermal imaging surveys to assess deer density at Ames AgResearch and Education Center (AmesREC) and the surrounding counties in West Tennessee. Deer density estimates did not significantly decline across the monitoring period despite consistently high prevalence of chronic wasting disease at AmesREC (CWD, >30% positive since 2020). We used deer capture data and stage-structured models to evaluate population-level processes that could promote an apparently stable deer density with high CWD prevalence. From January 2023 – June 2025, we captured adult deer (n = 84) and fitted them with Iridium Satellite GPS collars on AmesREC. We estimated adult survival rates from collared individuals. A subset of 23 females received vaginal implant transmitters to evaluate recruitment. To assess the potential for immigration, we collected hair for genetic analysis using 21 microsatellites. Yearly adult survival probabilities were statistically similar between males and females at 57%. Pregnancy rates were high (89%), including fawn pregnancies. We captured and collared 4 fawns for up to 20 days before collars were lost. Using our estimated vital rates the literature values, we parameterized a stage-structured model at AmesREC. All models predicted growth rates <1 without any immigration. We would have predicted an average of 23.57 – 25.93% annual decline in deer density based on our model. The AmesREC population was relatively genetically heterogeneous, with statistical evidence for contributions from 7 genetic sources, suggesting likely immigration. We found AmesREC was more genetically diverse than a nearby unhunted site Lone Oaks, even after controlling for sample size. Immigration may be acting in a compensatory manner to maintain population density at an apparently stable level in a population that would otherwise be suffering marked declines. As high-quality habitats open from local mortalities, deer dispersed from nearby locations with lower CWD prevalence are moving in to fill those previously occupied areas. We need to account for all factors affecting population growth rates and the possible contributions from surrounding areas with lower CWD prevalence. Populations should be monitored over time as CWD spreads and limits the possibility for immigration to maintain deer numbers.
Degree
Master of Science
Major
Wildlife & Fisheries Sciences
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
WYRICK-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
843.07 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
30a34ccd9a6686c08a035a7e0f1a19cc