The experiences of Autistic counselors in clinical supervision
Date Issued
August 2026
Author(s)
Irion, Brittney N. R.
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Melinda Gibbons
Additional Advisor(s)
Jamian Coleman
Jordan Westcott
Meredith Massey
Abstract
This dissertation comprises two manuscripts: a PRISMA-guided systematic review and a qualitative study. Both manuscripts focus on the experiences of Autistic individuals. As increasing numbers of Autistic individuals pursue higher education and careers in helping professions, greater attention is needed to understand how educational and professional environments support or hinder their development. This is particularly important in counseling and related fields, where relational competence is closely tied to training, evaluation, and professional advancement. The first manuscript is a PRISMA-guided systematic review of literature published between 2013 and 2025, using Education Source, PsycINFO, Scopus, and Web of Science. Thirteen articles were selected and analyzed using thematic analysis. Five themes were identified: Strengths and Purpose, Accommodations and Support, Barriers and Bias in Neurotypical Systems, Constant Adaptive Labor, and Toll of Navigating Neurotypical Systems. Findings suggested that many challenges emerged not from autism itself, but from navigating environments structured around neurotypical expectations. To build on these results, the second manuscript employed Reflexive Thematic Analysis to explore how Autistic pre-licensed and recently licensed counselors experience clinical supervision and the supervisory relationship. Eight Autistic counselors participated in semi-structured interviews focused on their supervision experiences during counselor training and early professional practice. Participants described supervision along three continua: Cultural Attunement to Cultural Misattunement, Mutual Connection to Hierarchical Disconnection, and Clear and Responsive Support to Ambiguous and Insufficient Support. Findings suggest that supervision can better support Autistic counselors' development when supervisors demonstrate cultural attunement to autism, foster relational safety, and provide clear, responsive developmental support. Together, these
results expand understanding of how neurotypical norms shape the experiences of Autistic individuals within helping professions and counselor training contexts. This research highlights the need for neurodiversity-affirming educational, supervisory, and professional practices that support Autistic individuals' well-being, development, and long-term participation in helping professions.
Subjects
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Counselor Education
Embargo Date
August 1, 2029