ENGAGEMENT AS A PROCESS OF POSITION INTERPRETATION AND MANAGEMENT: A PUBLIC-CENTERED APPROACH TO UNDERSTANDING ENGAGEMENT
Date Issued
August 2026
Author(s)
Kochigina, Anna
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Michael Palenchar
Additional Advisor(s)
Sally McMillan
Aimei Yang
Maureen Taylor
Abstract
The concept of engagement has been recognized as fundamental across numerous disciplines, including public relations, psychology, marketing, organization behavior, social and digital communication, education, anthropology, sociology, and health sciences. While across these disciplines, engagement is commonly defined as a state measured by cognitive, affective, and behavioral dimensions, scholars also recognize engagement as a process with participation, experience, and shared action at its core (Johnston & Taylor, 2018a). A few scholars (e.g., Hollebeek et al., 2023; Johnston & Lane, 2020) have suggested this process-nature of engagement is the concept’s key characteristic that distinguishes engagement from related concepts such as involvement, interest, commitment, and cocreation, among others. However, limited and inconsistent research has been dedicated to exploring engagement as a process. This dissertation addressed this gap by adopting a grounded theory approach to explore engagement as a meaningful and holistic process experienced by publics. Based on 24 intensive semi-structured interviews, the findings conceptualize engagement as a dynamic, networked process in which publics invest effort to make meaning and manage their positions. Interview data defined a position as an individual’s perceived standing in relation to a situation, issue, activity, organization, self, or others, while the engagement process is characterized by three elements: control, meaningfulness, and obligation, each having its own dimensions. Based on how individuals interpret changes in their positions, there are six engagement types: building, distancing, maintaining, advancing, accepting, and recovering or preventing harm to a position. Engagement types evolve and change during the engagement process, and individuals can experience multiple types of engagement simultaneously within a single interaction as they manage multiple positions. Together, the findings of the dissertation reframe engagement as a dynamic process of position interpretation and management, in which publics act as strategic agents, making decisions about how, when, and why to engage. Based on the findings, the dissertation proposes the Engagement Position Management Process that can be applied across disciplines. The dissertation also provides insight to public relations practitioners on how to engage publics with respect to the networked process of engagement.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Communication and Information
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
KOCHIGINA-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
1.86 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
ccf7d8dd09f4fed292b1c38149e1f895