A comparison of two methods of teaching six hemming techniques using single concept film loops
The design of the study was to compare a self-instructional method of teaching a unit on hems with the more conventional method of the lecture-demonstration. Single concept film loops and audio tapes were developed as the media for teaching six hemming techniques.
It was hypothesized that there would be no significant difference in learning between the two methods as measured by (a) a written pre-test, post-test, (b) a practical pre-test, post-test.
The sample was comprised of all students enrolled in a college level beginning clothing construction class fall semester, 1972. Because the course had no prerequisites and enrollment was limited in terms of space, an arbitrary decision was made to designate Section I as the experimental group and Section II as the control group. The selfinstructional method was used with the experimental group and the lecturedemonstration with the control group.
Six hemming techniques were selected for filming, and a commentary accompanying each filmed technique was placed on cassette tape. Prior to presentation of material in either teaching method, all students were given a written pre-test designed to measure knowledge of garment hems and a practical pre-test to demonstrate six specific hem techniques. At the conclusion of the teaching experiment the same written and practical tests were used as post-tests.
The following results were indicated upon analysis of the data. There was no significant difference in the level of learning of the two groups, self-instructional and lecture-demonstration, as measured by (a) the differences between the pre-test and post-test mean scores on the written test. There was a significant difference in the level of learning of the two groups as measured by (b) the differences between the practical pre-test, post-test mean scores; the t-test was highly significant at the .Ol level for the experimental group. In other words, the laboratory (experimental) proved superior for imparting the manual techniques used in hemming.
Thesis75.B763.pdf
1.96 MB
Adobe PDF
83a9f6bbdf97a0e23bef899e18b48340