The American political drama
With an initial proposition that, in America, "politics is what it is because people act as they do," the study attempts a partial test of that proposition by selecting "talk" as an activity--yielding a more limited proposition that, in America, "politics is what it is because, in part, people talk as they do." A review of some philosophical and political science literature suggests the importance of talk for politics. As a method whose terms for a rigorous analysis of talk are based on the referents of inquiry, Kenneth Burke's "dramatism" is introduced and applied in three ways: (1) the analysis of a number of previous works on American politics; (2) an experimental design to test for contemporary perspectives; and (3) a critique of some currently popular ways of theorizing about American politics.
To demonstrate how Burke's "dramatism" may be applied to existing literature, 10 works, concerned with a wide range of subjects and points of view, are selected for analysis. By use of Burke's "dramatistic ratios," and his dialectic, an in-depth examination of how each of the authors have featured their chosen aspects of American politics is conducted. Such analyses reveal those locations where ambiguities and inconsistencies arise as the results of terminological arrangements and metaphors or models by which the subject matters are represented.
Then, using Burke's terms and method, an experiment is designed and conducted. The experiment, which employs Q-methodology and its techniques in conjunction with Burke's terms, results in findings which describe two factors or groups of people (contemporary political scientists whose "field" is American politics) whose perspectives on American politics today is markedly different in some ways, but in other ways, a consensus may be found.
It is concluded that American politics may be usefully viewed as discourse when it comes to relating "thought and action" thematically, and that some currently popular metaphors or models used to theorize about American politics may be critically examined for their representations of political "realities" by using Burke's dramatism as a "metalanguage" or a "logology." And, by viewing political theorizing as inquiry, it may be useful to view that inquiring, itself, as political drama.
Thesis76b.W284.pdf
10.3 MB
Adobe PDF
77454c5f92022c61022a54d6dfbf67c6