Differences in the subjective experience of hypnosis. A comparison of female field-independent and female field-dependent subjects at three depths of hypnosis
This study was designed to assess differences in the subjective experience of hypnosis. The subjective experience of female field-independent and female field-dependent subjects was compared at light, medium and deep levels of hypnosis.
A total of two hundred undergraduate females from The University of Tennessee were tested on the Group Embedded Figures Test (EFT). Newey's (1975) criterion for field-independence/dependence was used in selecting one hundred and four subjects as field-independent or field-dependent. These subjects were assigned to one of two hypnotists for one session of individual hypnosis. The hypnotists were graduate students in clinical psychology and were trained in hypnotic technique. Neither hypnotist was aware of the subject's EFT score during the hypnosis session. A standard eye fixation technique was used for hypnotic induction followed by the Handler Hypnotic Deepening Steps (HHDS). Subjects were separated into light, medium and deep levels of hypnosis by the HHDS. In this manner, six groups of subjects were obtained: field-independent light, field-independent medium, field-independent deep, field-dependent light, field-dependent medium and field-dependent deep. Group size was limited to ten subjects and the first ten subjects who met the individual group criterion constituted each group.
Upon termination of trance, the subject was given a sixty-one item inventory of subjective experience. The items were adapted from the literature on the subjective experience of hypnosis and could be answered on a four-point scale. The questionnaire results were used to test the following hypotheses:
1. The female-field-independent group will perceive hypnosis as a challenge to its self control and will emphasize that control and autonomy is maintained during hypnosis. Conversely, the female-field dependent group will perceive hypnosis as a process of losing autonomy and self control. These subjects will acknowledge transfer of control to the hypnotist.
2. The female-field-independent group and the female-field-dependent group will differ least at a light level of trance where autonomy is threatened, and will differ most at a deep level of trance when autonomy is threatened to a greater degree.
The results indicate that Hypothesis l tends to be supported. Female-field-independent subjects tend to receive lower scores on the hypnosis inventory than female field-dependent subjects. Thus the field-independent subjects seem to be denying loss of control and autonomy to a greater extent than field-dependent subjects. Hypothesis 2 was not supported by the data. Tendencies were detected which indicate that the data was in the opposite direction predicted by Hypothesis 2. That is, the greatest differences in the subjective experience of hypnosis tended to be in the light level of hypnosis.
Implications of the above results were discussed in terms of lending further support to the work of Field (1965, 1973) and others who have argued that the subjective experience of hypnosis is not a unitary phenomenon. Such individual differences must be taken into account in any theory of hypnosis.
Thesis76b.S548.pdf
4.91 MB
Adobe PDF
a5e796c1f165ea98e1a425ad96e93ce8