A comparative study of norm- and criterion-referenced measures with an examination of the effects of manipulating instructional objectives and methods of study as they relate to student multiple-choice quiz performance
The study was conducted in order to compare a norm-referenced evaluative program with its criterion-referenced counterpart and to determine how they might affect student performance on an undergraduate multiple-choice quiz. The study was designed so as to appraise the performance of students who study individually for their quiz as opposed to those who choose to study with other subjects. Further, the effect of instructional objectives, designed to aid in the understanding of material to be mastered in preparation for a quiz, was also assessed. Thus, a total of three independent variables were under experimental scrutiny.
The 105 subjects who participated in this study were drawn from volunteer students enrolled in Educational Psychology 3810 at the University of Tennessee at Knoxville (Winter, 1976). Of these 105, 80 actually participated in the experiment, while the remaining 25 served as "alternates" in the event that a few of the subjects failed to appear at a pre-specified location at which the study was to be conducted. Since the study involved eight experimental conditions, ten subjects were randomly assigned to each cell in a statistical 2 x 2 x 2 Factorial ANOVA. Finally, the experiment consisted of three phases: the norm-referenced phase (6:00 p.m. - 7:20 p.m.), the criterion-referenced phase (8:05 p.m. - 9:25 p.m.) and the administration of the 24-item questionnaire after the NR Phase and the CR Phase of the Study (7:25 p.m. - 8:05 p.m. and 9:30 p.m. - 10:10 p.m., respectively).
Inspection and evaluation of the results revealed that if an instructor selects a multiple-choice examination to evaluate student progress, the method by which specific grades are awarded is of little significance in enhancing students' academic performance. Also, the results of the present study indicate no significant increase in the number of correct responses on a multiple-choice examination when instructional objectives were introduced or when the method by which a subject studies (alone or group) was manipulated.
An assumption can be made that in the present study both evaluative strategies optimized student motivation and, thus, the subjects were operating near their ceiling levels in both groups. If this, indeed, is the case, one would not expect differential performance levels between the two evaluational procedures.
Thesis76b.S337.pdf
3.84 MB
Adobe PDF
3134cc9145d40a61e531bd76f53edefa