Faculty classroom instructional performance as a function of the actual, ideal and importance responses of undergraduate college and university students
In recent years, specifically since 1969, much interest has been focused on the measurement of the difference between respondent's actual and ideal perceptions of various phenomena associated with the behavioral sciences. While many researchers have experimented with a variety of techniques and schemes, few absolute answers have been found and only tentative and primarily intuitively derived conclusions have been put forth. The proposed investigative design of this research study was constructed in such a way as to take advantage of the more concrete findings of recent years.
The major purpose of the study was to examine the predictive relationship between the student's perceptions of the actual, ideal, and derived discrepancy scores for 26 well-defined behaviors and activities commonly viewed as critical to the assessment of excellence in the classroom instructional setting, and the student's overall evaluation of the professor's instructional performance in the classroom. A secondary purpose involved the investigation into the role of the student's perception of the importance of each of the 26 well-defined behaviors and activities. Contingent on the attainment of a suitable level of predictive relationship between the 26 behaviors and activities and the student's overall instructional performance evaluation, an ancillary purpose of the study was to explore the possibility of using student assigned boundary points (actual and ideal) and the resultant discrepancy score to differentiate between levels of instructional performance.
A total of 3109 student questionnaires, representing the assessment 120 undergraduate classroom instructors from the University of Tennessee, Knoxville and Maryville College, Maryville, Tennessee were analyzed. The research questionnaire measured the student's perceptions of three dimensional aspects (the importance category and the actual and ideal categories of frequency of occurrence) for each of 26 well-defined behaviors and activities commonly held to be contributory to excellence in classroom instruction. The two frequency of occurrence categories, actual/is and ideal/should be, were measured on a seven (7) point semantic scale ranging from never to always. The instrument also surveyed the student's perception of the importance of each behavior or activity on a five (5) point semantic scale ranging from not important to extremely important. The overall evaluation of classroom instructional performance was measured on a nine (9) point semantic scale ranging from very worst to very best. The absolute difference between the actual and ideal responses was termed the discrepancy score and was used as a measure of the student's satisfaction with a particular behavior or activity.
By comparison within and between categories of data and by comparison of the relevant categories with the overall evaluation of classroom instructional performance scores the following results were obtained:
1. Real category scores for the 26 well-defined behaviors and activities were found to be better predictors of the overall evaluation scores than the corresponding discrepancy scores.
2. The importance category was found to be most directly related to the ideal category. This relationship was perceived as introducing considerable measurement error into the importance mean scores for four of the 26 statements which were focused on ineffective behaviors and activities.
3. Real category scores for the 26 well-defined behaviors and activities were found to be slightly more reliable than the corresponding discrepancy scores when reliability was computed by using the split-half method and subsequently corrected by the Spearman-Brown Prophecy Formula.
4. The mean overall evaluation score for each professor, generally varied inversely with its standard deviation as the mean increased from five to eight and one-half. The consequence of this finding was that for the professors represented it was not practical to attempt to investigate the discriminating power of the 26 behaviors and activities between classes.
Thesis76b.Q837.pdf
4.2 MB
Adobe PDF
b054faeaf94562c89f4a83cc39fe7a4a