A needs-goals assessment of a community organization (police department) from a general systems perspective
The application of the general systems perspective to goals-analysis of a community organization was investigated using a Police Department as a focal organization. The relevance of this perspective to organizational analysis is examined through an empirical analysis of the priorities assigned by three groups--Police Department employees, police managers, and representatives of the general public--to statements describing the various goals a police department might seek to accomplish.
The study presupposes that goals be clearly defined and consensual to assure the effectiveness of the organization.
Paradoxically, there is considerable ambiguity concerning what goals an organization should pursue, in particular in the case of police departments. An especially controversial question is whether a Police Department should include social service functions with its primary law enforcement and deterrence objectives.
The goal perceptions of patrolmen, management, and the public are compared for "as is" and "as should be" conditions using a 57 item questionnaire generated by the respondents. The samples were selected on the basis of their reputed leadership among their peer group.
For purposes of this analysis, organizational analysis was defined as goal consensus among employees, managers, and public, "as is" and "as should be." A significant difference between the two conditions was shown. It was interpreted as demonstrating organizational ineffectiveness. Efficiency was assessed by comparing the degree of goal consensus between employees and management. Employees perceived a significant difference between present and ideal perceptions. Neither management nor the public shared this perception. Employees alone perceived the organization as inefficient.
The organizational priorities for each group were determined and compared for high, medium, and low priorities in both "as is" and "as should be" conditions. Different goals were dominant for each group, suggesting the valence of different needs for each group.
Commonalities and differences in the perceptions between each group were identified. A higher correlation between the perceptions of employees and the public, than between employees and management was shown. Management and employees share more priorities with the public than with each other, in both the present and ideal department.
It is concluded that considerable areas of agreement and disagreement exist in the Department. There is an emphatic consensus that the social service function is not and should not be part of the police role. Greatest disparities center around the job context factors (the working conditions surrounding the job) rather than on job content factors (the work tasks themselves).
Thesis76b.O353.pdf
2.44 MB
Adobe PDF
6bfc46243534a7ba74022a0b67d54490