Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Doctoral Dissertations
  5. The relationship between congruent student and supervisor expectations, student performance, and student satisfaction in counseling practica
Details

The relationship between congruent student and supervisor expectations, student performance, and student satisfaction in counseling practica

Date Issued
June 1976
Author(s)
Morgan, Susan Marney
Advisor(s)
John W. Edgerly
Additional Advisor(s)
Kathy Davis
Karen Swander
Ken Newton
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/61342
Abstract

The central focus of this study was to consider the effects of the congruency between student and supervisor expectations on the outcome of supervision specifically in terms of student performance and student satisfaction in counseling practica. An additional concern was to examine the process of change to determine if students in this study do in fact become more congruent with their supervisors and when this change in attitude occurs during supervision. Secondary concerns of this study were attempts to define and describe supervisory style. Finally, an effort was made to comment on the reliability of the Supervisory Role Analysis Form (SRAF) since this was the instrument used in this study.

Congruency between student and supervisor expectations was measured by determining the amount of agreement which students and supervisors obtained when compared to each other on various administrations of the SRAF. Students were administered the SRAF at the beginning, middle, and end of practica while supervisors were administered the SRAF at the beginning and end of practica. The subjects in this study were twenty-three counseling students across three levels of practica experience and five supervisors-three humanistic, one behavioral, and one eclectic. Supervisors were asked to rate students overall performance in practica on a one to five scale and students were asked to rate their satisfaction with practica on a one to five scale. Both measurements were taken at the end of practica. It was found that there was no discernable relationship between degree of agreement and student performance ratings and that there was a negative correlation between degree of agreement and student satisfaction. Previous research has suggested that change does occur during supervision and that this change generally occurs in the beginning phases of practica. It has been suggested that students also change to become more like their supervisor in orientation. Using a didactic-experiential scale of the SRAF in addition to the agreement scores found by comparing various administrations of the SRAF, it was found that there is a significantly greater change in student attitudes during the first four weeks of practica than in the last four weeks. The contention that students would change in the amount of agreement with their supervisor on the SRAF from the beginning to the end of practica and the contention that practica level would differentially affect the amount of change were not supported. The contention that students would become more like their supervisor in orientation was also not supported. It appeared that both students and supervisors changed positions during the supervisory process.

Supervisory style in this study was examined by determining scores on the didactic-experiential scale of the SRAF, by asking supervisors to specify their theoretical orientation, by asking supervisors to respond to a semantic differential, and by asking supervisors to specify what they did in practica. It was found that humanistic and nonhumanistic supervisors do not score significantly different on the didactic-experiential scale of the SRAF. These two groups, however, do score significantly different on all of the concepts rated on the semantic differential except four. The humanistic supervisors also rated all concepts more extremely in a positive direction than did the nonhumanistic supervisors. All supervisors indicated that they used a combination of skills acquisition and attention to the relationship in response to the behavior item.

Finally, an index of agreement was tabulated for the SRAF. It was found that the degree of agreement was significantly greater than that which could have occurred by chance alone in a test-retest situation. Subjects for this part of the study were forty-five students, nineteen in Prepracticum and twenty-six in classes offered to helping professionals. It was also found that the SRAF was more reliable for the Prepracticum group than the Helping Professional Group in a test-retest situation.

The possible applications of this research were discussed and areas of future research were cited. Among the suggestions were further examination of the process of supervision, the determination of the effects of clarifying expectations with students through various methods, and the emphasis in future research on behavioral studies with the further refinement of instruments and descriptions and the rejection of imposed categories such as "didactic" and "experiential" or "humanistic" and "nonhumanistic."

Degree
Doctor of Education
Major
Educational Psychology and Guidance
File(s)
Thumbnail Image
Name

Thesis76b.M675.pdf

Size

4.34 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

2c4410e1151541a00cad8f5d84912f25


University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science