Dreikurs' goals of misbehavior theory : child and teacher generation of a neo-Adlerian construct
Adler's theory of personality was forwarded by Dreikurs who, in attempting to develop specific Adlerian techniques, modified some of Adler's concepts. Dreikurs' four goals of misbehavior theory were discussed in this context. Child and teacher ability to generate goals of misbehavior (via nominal group technique), teacher methods of classifying the statements teachers generated, and teacher and school psychologist ability to classify goals in a Dreikurs format plus an Other category were assessed. The intrarater consistency and interrater agreement of classification judgements was tested. In addition, three psychologists knowledgeable in the area of Individual Psychology classified child and teacher generated statements as to their interpersonal quality and goal orientation. In all, 36 children (6 each from grades 3, 5, 6, 7, 8, and 12), 24 elementary school teachers, 6 school psychologists, and 3 psychologists familiar with Adler and Dreikurs took part in this study.
Children generated 52 different statements and teachers 62. Results indicated that although children and teachers are able to formulate interpersonal goal statements, the task is a difficult one, particularly for teachers. Teachers seemed to feel that setting events and. instincts were major factors controlling children's misbehavior. Teacher agreement as to classification of teacher generated statements within Dreikurs' categories varied widely. The majority of school psychologists placed the majority of statements into categories with intrarater consistency and interrater agreement. The three psychologists familiar with Adler and Dreikurs were in perfect agreement on approximately half of the statements--slightly higher agreement was found on goal status judgements than on judgements of interpersonal quality. Two new goals are suggested and a justification for further research on, and increased use of, Adlerian premises and Dreikursian methodology is offered.
Thesis76b.M288.pdf
5.74 MB
Adobe PDF
3cb899a0b752709325ea42c60df98e0b